← Front pageReports · Watch · Archive
DRASKER

DRASKER REPORT

updated · revision 3 · Updated October 23, 2026

Mullin rejects pause in ICE enforcement after Bronx shooting

The accounts of why officers fired remain disputed: DHS has said the man did not comply with orders, while released footage does not capture the shots.2,4

The shooting also prompted calls from New York officials to halt enforcement and renewed attention to the city's legal fight over ICE access to Rikers Island.3,6

KEY POINTS
  • NYPD Commissioner Jessica Tisch said two plainclothes ICE officers approached Belgal's vehicle in Marble Hill and that he was shot in the neck; Mullin said ICE would not pause New York enforcement.6
  • The New York Times' review of NYPD-released footage found an officer approach Belgal's parked car with a gun drawn, the car pull away as the officer struck a window, and armed officers converge after a crash; the clips do not show the shooting.4
  • Mullin said officials sought Belgal because they believed he had knowledge of a 2025 shooting that injured an off-duty customs officer; DHS separately said he did not comply with lawful orders.2,4
  • New York officials called for a halt to operations, while a state judge had already invalidated the Adams administration's order to open an ICE office at Rikers Island.3,6
  • The released clips do not establish the precise moment or immediate trigger of the shooting, and the subject's current medical condition and detention location remain unclear.4,5
WHAT WE KNOW

An ICE shooting in the Bronx left Oscar Belgal wounded, and DHS Secretary Markwayne Mullin said Friday that the agency would continue enforcement in New York rather than pause operations.6

The released video documents part of the encounter but does not show the moment of the shooting, leaving a central question about the sequence of events unresolved.4

The encounter and what the video shows

At a Thursday evening news conference, NYPD Commissioner Jessica Tisch said two plainclothes ICE officers approached a vehicle as it backed into a parking spot in Marble Hill and that a man identified as Oscar Belgal, 28, was shot in the neck.6

The New York Times described NYPD-released body-camera and surveillance footage showing an immigration officer in plain clothes approaching Belgal's parked car with a gun drawn. The car pulls away as the armed man strikes its window; other armed plainclothes officers then converge on the crashed vehicle.4

Those clips do not show the shooting itself. The footage therefore leaves the precise moment of the shots and the immediate actions preceding them unresolved.4

Tisch said Belgal was in the car with his five-year-old son, who was not injured; Mullin said ICE officers did not know a child was in the vehicle when they opened fire.4

The stated basis for the operation

At a news conference, DHS Secretary Markwayne Mullin said agents had been trying to arrest Belgal, whom he described as an undocumented immigrant with a criminal record. Mullin cited a 2023 guilty plea for grand larceny and a 2025 controlled-substance sale charge, and said officials believed Belgal had direct or indirect knowledge of a July 2025 shooting in Manhattan that injured an off-duty customs officer.4

DHS said Belgal refused to comply with lawful orders during the targeted operation. That is the department's account of his conduct; the released clips do not show the shooting itself.2,4

ICE officials, as reported by the Daily Mail, alleged that Belgal weaponized his vehicle and drove it at agents.5

At the October 13, 2026 gubernatorial debate, Nassau County Executive Bruce Blakeman described Belgal as having entered the country illegally and cited a prior conviction, pending drug-dealing charges and gang affiliation; he blamed the shooting on Gov. Kathy Hochul's sanctuary policies.2

Detention and court proceedings

The New York Times reported that Belgal's lawyers filed an emergency petition and that Manhattan federal judge John P. Cronan ordered immigration officials not to remove him from the country before the petition was heard.4

At a Friday hearing, Assistant U.S. Attorney Brandon Waterman said Belgal had been booked at the Brooklyn Metropolitan Detention Center. His lawyers said he had spent the prior night in custody in Elizabeth, New Jersey, with the bullet still in his body.4

The Daily Mail separately reported that Judge J. Paul Oetken barred Belgal's deportation to the Dominican Republic while his challenge to ICE detention was pending and limited transfers to facilities in New York's Southern or Eastern Districts.5

The Daily Mail, citing Belgal's attorneys through Courthouse News, also reported that ICE had moved him from a hospital to an unknown location and that his name did not appear in ICE's online detainee portal. The attorneys expressed concern about his health and well-being in a Friday court filing.5

A dispute over whether enforcement should continue

Mullin said Friday that ICE would not pause enforcement in New York, adding that the agency's job was to enforce federal law and pursue what he called “the worst of the worst.”6

Gov. Kathy Hochul said she asked Mullin and President Donald Trump to halt ICE operations in New York immediately.6

At the October 13 debate, Hochul called Blakeman's response a “non-answer” and said ICE agents shoot into cars without knowing who is inside, adding that a five-year-old could have been killed.2

Blakeman said at the debate that he had a cooperative agreement with ICE and that his county had removed more than 2,000 migrants with criminal records while cooperating with the agency. He also said Hochul had told localities they could no longer cooperate with ICE.2

The Daily Mail reported that Mayor Zohran Mamdani said he had spoken with Trump and Mullin to demand ICE agents leave New York City; it also reported that Hochul urged a halt to enforcement and the release of body-camera footage.5

The existing fight over ICE access to Rikers

Before the Bronx shooting, a New York State Supreme Court judge, Mary Rosado, issued a final decision invalidating Mayor Eric Adams's Executive Order 50, which would have opened an ICE office on Rikers Island. The City Council said the decision found the order “null and void” under the city charter because it created an impermissible appearance of a conflict of interest.3

The Council described the decision as the fourth consecutive ruling against the Adams administration's effort to give ICE and other federal agencies special access to Rikers, following an interim restraining order, a restraining order and a preliminary injunction.3

In its lawsuit, the Council argued that the order was the “poisoned fruit” of a deal between Adams and the Trump administration, alleging that Adams allowed ICE onto Rikers in exchange for dismissal of criminal charges against him. That was the Council's litigation argument.3

At a September 16, 2025 press conference, City Council Speaker Adrienne Adams, council members and immigrant-rights organizations said they would continue opposing federal immigration enforcement and defending New York City's sanctuary laws.3

TIMELINE
  1. City Council members and immigrant-rights organizations said they would continue resisting federal immigration enforcement and upholding the city's sanctuary laws.3

  2. Fox News, citing local media and police, reported that ICE agents shot Oscar Belgal during an immigration operation in the Bronx.1

  3. Mullin said ICE would not pause enforcement activities in New York following the shooting.6

  4. At the New York gubernatorial debate, Blakeman blamed Hochul's sanctuary policies for the shooting; Hochul criticized his response and ICE's use of force around vehicles.2

WHAT WE STILL DON'T KNOW
  • The precise moment of the shooting and the immediate actions triggering it, as the released video does not show it.
  • The current medical condition of Oscar Belgal and the location of his detention, as accounts conflict and rely on attorney allegations.
  • Independent verification of ICE's claims that Belgal 'weaponized his vehicle' or drove at agents.
  • Independent verification of the specific criminal allegations and gang affiliation claims made by DHS and Blakeman against Belgal.
  • The operational details and legal authority for the specific ICE enforcement action in the Bronx.
  • The outcome and details of any internal review or disciplinary proceedings related to the shooting by DHS or ICE.
SOURCES
  1. 1.
  2. 2.
  3. 3.
  4. 4.
  5. 5.
  6. 6.
REVISION HISTORY
  • Revision 3 · October 23, 2026 · material update
  • Revision 2 · October 16, 2026 · material update
  • Revision 1 · October 11, 2026