← Front pageReports · Watch · Archive
DRASKER

DRASKER REPORT

published · Updated October 27, 2026

EPA withdraws one methane-related rule as broader rewrite looms

The withdrawn 2023 provision concerned emergency-related defenses in Title V permits. The EPA says its separate OOOOb/c standards cover new, modified and reconstructed sources and existing sources.4,5

The EPA’s FAQ lists topics addressed by the original standards, including leaks, control devices, associated gas and the Super Emitter Program.5

KEY POINTS
  • The EPA withdrew the 2023 affirmative-defense rule, which had removed emergency-related defenses from Title V permit regulations; the agency says the withdrawal follows a 2025 appeals-court decision.4
  • The EPA says its OOOOb/c standards address new, modified and reconstructed sources and existing sources; its FAQ lists topics including leaks, control devices, associated gas and the Super Emitter Program.5
  • News reports describe a forthcoming reconsideration that could alter marginal-well standards and rescind the Super Emitter Program; Zeldin has said the existing rule does not sufficiently distinguish small operators from major companies.2
  • Zeldin put the stated savings from the administration’s changes at $45 billion; The Verge reported that the prior rules were projected to cut methane emissions 80 percent over 14 years and bring up to $98 billion in benefits. These are different estimates, and the claims cited here do not provide an updated EPA analysis of the proposed changes.3
  • The precise revised requirements, projected emissions and costs, and schedule for the OOOOb/c proposal remain unresolved.1
WHAT WE KNOW

The Environmental Protection Agency has withdrawn a 2023 Biden-era rule that removed emergency-related affirmative defenses from Title V air permits, saying it acted to comply with a 2025 decision by the U.S. Court of Appeals for the D.C. Circuit.4

Separately, EPA Administrator Lee Zeldin has described a forthcoming reconsideration of the Biden-era oil and gas methane standards. The Washington Examiner and Mother Jones have reported potential changes to marginal-well requirements and the Super Emitter Program, but the specific proposal has not been published, according to those reports.1,2

Two actions, with different legal and regulatory scope

The withdrawal already announced by the EPA concerns the 2023 Affirmative Defense Rule. That rule had rescinded emergency-related affirmative-defense provisions in Title V operating-permit regulations at 40 C.F.R. 70.6(g) and 71.6(g).4

The EPA says it withdrew the rule to comply with the D.C. Circuit’s 2025 decision in SSM Litigation Group v. EPA, which reversed the 2023 rule. The agency says the restored regulations allow facilities to demonstrate that excess emissions resulted from unavoidable emergencies or malfunctions; it also says state, local and Tribal permitting agencies no longer have to revise permit programs or existing permits to comply with the 2023 rule.4

The agency says the withdrawal takes effect upon publication in the Federal Register, creates no new regulatory requirements and restores the pre-2023 framework.4

The broader OOOOb/c rules are a separate matter. The EPA says its final standards for new, modified and reconstructed sources, and emissions guidelines for existing sources, were published in the Federal Register on March 8, 2024.5

What the forthcoming reconsideration may cover

At a New Mexico Oil and Gas Association meeting in Santa Fe, Zeldin said the agency was “within days” of releasing a draft reconsideration of the Biden-era methane rule, Mother Jones reported. The publication described the expected draft as potentially weakening requirements for leaks, venting and flaring, changing controls for older and leakier wells, and rescinding the Super Emitter Program; those details are reporting about a proposal, not a published final rule.1

The Washington Examiner, in reporting carried by MSN, said the agency would propose two options for marginal wells, with separate standards for different well types. The same report said the EPA had described marginal wells as accounting for less than 5 percent of U.S. oil and gas supply but nearly 50 percent of industry methane emissions.2

The Washington Examiner also reported that the proposal would rescind the Super Emitter Program, divide standards for covers and closed vent systems, revisit associated gas from oil wells, and make technical changes involving flame-monitoring data deviations, control-device alerts and visible-emissions test conditions.2

The Verge described the expected changes as including an end to the program, which it said notified operators about large methane releases of at least 100 kilograms per hour. The Washington Examiner also reported that the EPA planned to rescind the program; both accounts describe a proposed rather than completed change.2,3

Zeldin told the Washington Examiner that he viewed the existing rule as insufficiently attentive to differences between small operators and major companies. He also said the Super Emitter provision had been presented to him as less controversial on questions of legal authority and interpretability, and that the agency would follow its statutory obligations using what he called the “single best reading” of federal law.2

Operators, exposure and the limits of the available detail

The New York Times reported that the proposed changes would relax requirements affecting hundreds of thousands of marginal oil and gas wells nearing the end of their useful lives and producing relatively little. The Times said, citing the agency’s prior statements, that marginal wells accounted for around 7 percent of U.S. oil and gas production but roughly half of industry methane emissions.6

Other reported figures differ: the Washington Examiner said the EPA put marginal wells’ share of supply below 5 percent, while The Verge, citing ProPublica, put their share of U.S. oil and gas production at 6 percent. The reported figures therefore vary; the claims do not specify the underlying measures and well definitions.2,3,6

The New York Times also reported that the Biden administration issued rules in 2023 requiring facilities to monitor operations and prevent methane leaks, and that the Trump administration had already delayed those rules from taking effect.6

Mother Jones, citing agency visitor logs, reported at least three dozen EPA meetings with oil and gas industry representatives during the first year of Trump’s second term to discuss methane regulations. The publication also cited Julia Kane’s Fieldnotes reporting that industry groups and companies—including the IPAA-led stripper-well coalition, the American Petroleum Institute, Continental Resources, Chord Energy and Kraken Oil & Gas Partners—pushed to weaken or avoid methane rules.1

The cost and emissions estimates are not directly comparable

Zeldin said in an October 7 press release that the rollbacks would save oil and gas companies $45 billion and that the previous rules would have incurred $18 billion in regulatory costs. In a statement quoted by Mother Jones, he described the measure as saving taxpayers $45 billion and said Americans could not afford energy when producers were burdened by what he called unnecessary requirements.1,3

The Verge reported that the Biden-era rules were expected to reduce methane emissions by 80 percent over 14 years and were estimated to yield up to $98 billion in benefits, including up to $13 billion in recovered natural gas. The claim does not identify the underlying analysis, and it describes estimates for the earlier rules rather than an updated assessment of the proposed revisions.3

These figures describe different items: the administration’s stated savings and cost figure, and reported projections of the previous rules’ emissions reductions and benefits. The available claims do not provide an EPA estimate of the revised rules’ expected emissions, compliance costs or economic benefits.3

What remains pending

Mother Jones reported Zeldin’s announcement that the agency was close to issuing a draft reconsideration; the Washington Examiner separately reported that he said the proposal was days, not weeks, away and that he still needed to read the final proposal before making a final decision.1,2

The New York Times, citing two unnamed administration officials, reported that President Trump was expected to announce a plan to loosen methane rules at a Tuesday campaign rally in Texas with Senate candidate Ken Paxton. That was a report about an anticipated announcement, not confirmation that the event occurred.6

Mother Jones, citing E&E News and two unnamed sources briefed on the rule, reported that the agency’s move could leave open the possibility of ultimately opting out of regulating methane from oil and gas operations. That possibility is not established as an agency decision.1

The EPA’s FAQ identifies subject areas covered by the existing standards. The Washington Examiner reported that the forthcoming proposal would address several of those areas, but did not provide the proposal’s regulatory text, supporting legal and technical analysis, updated impact estimates or schedule for public comment and finalization.2,5

TIMELINE
  1. The Biden-era Affirmative Defense Rule rescinded emergency-related affirmative-defense provisions in Title V permit regulations; the EPA later withdrew that rule.4

  2. The EPA says its final OOOOb/c standards were published in the Federal Register.5

  3. The D.C. Circuit issued the decision that the EPA says required withdrawal of the 2023 Affirmative Defense Rule.4

  4. Zeldin said in an EPA press release that the rollbacks would save oil and gas companies $45 billion and that the prior rules would have incurred $18 billion in regulatory costs.3

  5. The New York Times reported, citing two unnamed administration officials, that Trump was expected to announce a plan to loosen methane rules at a Tuesday Texas rally.6

  6. The New York Times reported that the EPA was moving to relax requirements affecting marginal wells; the report also described their relatively low output and nearing end of useful life.6

WHAT WE STILL DON'T KNOW
  • What specific regulatory text is being amended in the OOOOb/c reconsideration, and what are the exact new requirements for marginal wells, fugitive emissions, and the Super Emitter Program?
  • What is the legal and technical rationale contained within the proposed rule's preamble and supporting analysis for each of the major changes (e.g., rescinding the Super Emitter Program, creating separate standards for well types)?
  • What are the EPA's updated estimates for the projected change in methane emissions, compliance costs, and economic benefits resulting from the proposed revisions?
  • What is the precise effective date for the proposed changes to OOOOb/c, and what is the timeline for the public comment period and finalization?
  • Which specific oil and gas facility categories and operator sizes are most affected by the changes to marginal well regulations and the withdrawal of the affirmative defense rule?
  • What, if any, legal challenges have been filed or are anticipated in response to the EPA's withdrawal of the 2023 Affirmative Defense Rule and its forthcoming methane rule proposal?
SOURCES
  1. 1.
  2. 2.
  3. 3.
  4. 4.
  5. 5.
  6. 6.