← Front pageReports · Watch · Archive
DRASKER

DRASKER REPORT

published · Updated November 5, 2026

San Jose Officer Fired for Flock Camera Misuse Amid Broader Scrutiny of ALPR Systems

Chief Joseph said he could not disclose the internal probe during public hearings without jeopardizing disciplinary proceedings.3

The case adds to a documented national pattern of law enforcement misuse of automated license plate readers.1

KEY POINTS
  • A San Jose police officer was fired after allegedly accessing Flock ALPR data on a personal phone and sharing the location of a woman with a family member accused of abusing her, according to Chief Paul Joseph.5
  • The department discovered the misuse in February 2025 after the victim reported her abuser knew her location, and Chief Joseph was aware of the internal investigation in March 2026 when he publicly assured the City Council of the system's security.2,5
  • The Santa Clara County District Attorney's Office declined to file criminal charges against the officer, though the department referred the case there and to the state's peace officer standards commission.5
  • In response, San Jose introduced a new package of ALPR safeguard proposals in 2026, including measures to restrict access on personal devices and reduce data retention from one year to 30 days.2
  • National analyses and advocacy groups have documented over 100 instances of officer misuse of license plate reader technology, including at least 19 law enforcement employees arrested, fired, or investigated across five states, according to reports cited by Hoodline.1
WHAT WE KNOW

The San Jose Police Department fired an officer in September 2026 for allegedly using the city's Flock Safety automated license plate reader (ALPR) system to share a woman's location with a family member accused of abusing her, Chief Paul Joseph told NBC Bay Area.5

The department learned of the officer's actions in February 2025, SJPD officials said, after the woman reported that her alleged abuser knew where she was.2,5

Chief Joseph acknowledged that during a March 2026 City Council meeting where he stated internal audits showed ALPR data had 'not gone anywhere it isn't supposed to go,' he was simultaneously aware of the internal investigation into the officer's data misuse.2

The San Jose Incident: Firing and Investigation Timeline

The San Jose Police Department terminated an officer in September 2026 for misconduct involving the city's Flock Safety automated license plate reader (ALPR) system, Chief Paul Joseph told NBC Bay Area.5

According to Joseph, the officer accessed Flock data without authorization on a personal phone to locate the vehicle of a woman allegedly abused by one of the officer's family members, then sent that information to his cousin.5

SJPD officials said the department learned of the officer's actions in February 2025.2

Joseph said police discovered the unauthorized access when the woman told them her alleged abuser knew her location; the department then placed the officer on administrative leave and began a criminal investigation.5

The department referred the case to the Santa Clara County District Attorney's Office, but the officer was not charged with a crime; SJPD also referred the officer to the Commission on Peace Officer Standards and Training.5

Chief Joseph's Public Statements and Internal Awareness

During a March 2026 City Council meeting, Mayor Matt Mahan asked Chief Joseph directly whether San Jose had experienced any unauthorized access breaches or improper disclosures of ALPR data.2

Joseph responded, 'No we have not.'2

Joseph later acknowledged that during that same March council meeting, he was aware of an internal investigation into an officer who had allegedly improperly accessed Flock data on a personal device.2

At that meeting, Joseph also told the council that internal audits found the ALPR data 'has not gone anywhere it isn't supposed to go.'2

Joseph now says his March answer was limited to questions about data reaching unauthorized law enforcement agencies or being used for immigration enforcement.2

Joseph said he could not publicly disclose the investigation without jeopardizing ongoing disciplinary proceedings.3

Local Policy Response and System Scale

Following news of the firing in September 2026, the city introduced a second package of ALPR safeguard proposals.2,3

The proposed measures include making it harder for employees to access sensitive law enforcement data on personal devices and reducing data retention from one year to 30 days.2

Some proposals can be implemented immediately, while others require further council action, San Jose Spotlight reported.3

Chief Joseph said San Jose's ALPR network comprises 500 cameras supplied by Atlanta-based firm Flock Safety.2,3

National Context of ALPR Misuse

The Institute for Justice has catalogued more than 100 instances nationwide of officers using license plate reader technology for non-law-enforcement purposes or stalking, including two cases in Tennessee, Hoodline reported, citing Route Fifty.1

A USA Today analysis of more than 75 million Flock searches across 6,300 agencies over three and a half years found at least 19 police and sheriff's-office employees in five states arrested, fired, placed on leave, or under investigation for potentially improper use of the system, Hoodline reported, citing the Lufkin Daily News.1

Hoodline also reported a series of comparable Flock misuse cases from other outlets, including a fired Stow, Massachusetts officer facing criminal charges and two fired New Bedford, Massachusetts officers.1

According to data from Secure Justice cited by The Oak Leaf, 220 jurisdictions have canceled or rejected Flock Safety contracts over the past five years, 93 of them in August 2026 alone, out of more than 5,000 police jurisdictions Flock says it serves nationwide.4

TIMELINE
  1. The San Jose Police Department learns of an officer's alleged misuse of Flock ALPR data, according to SJPD officials.2

  2. During a City Council meeting, Chief Paul Joseph states internal audits show ALPR data has 'not gone anywhere it isn't supposed to go' and tells Mayor Matt Mahan the city has not experienced unauthorized access breaches.2

  3. Chief Joseph is simultaneously aware of an internal investigation into the officer's alleged data misuse, he later acknowledges.2

  4. The San Jose Police Department fires the officer for allegedly sharing Flock data with a domestic-violence suspect, Chief Joseph tells NBC Bay Area.1,5

  5. Following news of the firing, the city introduces a second package of ALPR safeguard proposals.2

WHAT WE STILL DON'T KNOW
  • The specific legal grounds cited by the Santa Clara County District Attorney's Office for declining to file criminal charges against the officer.
  • The findings and conclusions of the San Jose Police Department's internal affairs investigation, and whether the report is publicly available.
  • Whether the officer had a prior history of misconduct complaints, and whether Flock system access logs or digital forensics were used as evidence in the investigation.
  • The precise impact of the data misuse on the investigation and outcome of the underlying domestic violence case.
  • The specific internal audit trails or policies that flagged the misuse, and the exact timing of when the breach was detected by the system (as opposed to reported by the victim).
  • The current status of any administrative appeal of the officer's termination or any pending civil litigation related to the incident.
SOURCES
  1. 1.
  2. 2.
  3. 3.
  4. 4.
  5. 5.