Comey’s new case hinges on a ten-year deadline
The allegations concern staff contacts with New York Times reporter Charlie Savage about an earlier Reuters story and the paper’s October 5, 2016 report on Yahoo email surveillance. Public descriptions do not identify the information prosecutors say was conveyed.1,2,4,16
- The October 5, 2026 filing charged Comey under 18 U.S.C. §§ 793(d) and 793(g), and was made public on October 26; NBC News reported at unsealing that no indictment had been obtained in this case.8,16
- Prosecutors link the allegations to staff contacts with Charlie Savage about Reuters coverage and the Times’ October 5, 2016 Yahoo surveillance article; the public accounts do not specify the allegedly conveyed information.1,2,4,16
- Comey’s lawyers argue that an indictment, not a waiverless information, was required within ten years; the Justice Department says filing the information tolled the limitations period, and the legal dispute has not been resolved in the reported court proceedings.1,11,16
- Comey denies the charges. His lawyer says two earlier prosecutorial teams declined charges, but the underlying investigative records and their full findings are not public in the accounts summarized here.1,11,22,23
- The Virginia false-statements case was dismissed on prosecutor-appointment grounds, while the North Carolina seashell-post indictment remains a separate proceeding; neither determines the allegations in the D.C. information.9,21
A federal court in Washington made public a criminal information accusing former FBI Director James Comey of two offenses tied to an alleged 2016 disclosure: willfully communicating national-defense information to someone not entitled to receive it, and conspiring to do so. The information was filed under seal on October 5, 2026, and unsealed October 26; it is not a grand-jury indictment.9,10,16
The prosecution’s public account describes Comey directing staff or other intermediaries to speak with a Times reporter; it does not allege in the described account that Comey personally delivered the information to the reporter. Comey denies wrongdoing, while his lawyers say the filing came too late to meet the deadline for an indictment.1,15,16
Filed under seal, then unsealed
The filing made public on October 26, 2026, was a criminal information—not a grand jury indictment—in United States v. James Brien Comey Jr., in federal court in Washington, D.C. Prosecutors filed it under seal on October 5, and Judge Trevor McFadden granted the government’s request to keep it sealed that day, citing an ongoing criminal investigation, CNBC reports from court records.10,16
Comey’s lawyers moved to dismiss the case on October 9 and also sought to make the filing public; McFadden agreed to unseal it on October 26 at their request, CNBC reports. Reuters likewise reports that the information was filed October 5 and that court documents were made public October 26.4,10
The public document is described by the BBC as a three-page criminal information containing two counts. The filing’s existence and unsealing do not establish that a grand jury returned an indictment, that Comey was convicted, or that the limitations dispute has been resolved; NBC News reported that he had not been indicted in this case when it reported the unsealing.16,23
The docket is identified in the assignment as United States v. James Brien Comey Jr., D.D.C. No. 1:26-cr-00229 (TNM). The cited reporting establishes the filing and unsealing sequence, but does not itself establish the later status of any grand-jury presentation or return.10,16
Two counts, and an alleged chain through staff
The criminal information charges Comey under 18 U.S.C. § 793(d) with knowingly and willfully causing national-defense information to be communicated to a person not entitled to receive it, and under § 793(g) with conspiring to violate that provision. The charging language identifies national-defense information; news accounts sometimes use “classified information” as shorthand, but the public account does not establish that the alleged material’s classification status is specified. The available descriptions establish the charged conduct, but do not set out every statutory element or the government’s proof of each one.9,10,25
For the § 793(d) count, prosecutors allege that Comey caused the disclosure through others, rather than personally transmitting the information. The § 793(g) count alleges a conspiracy to commit the underlying offense; CNBC describes the information as alleging that Comey acted through one or more co-conspirators to direct an unnamed individual to disclose the information to a reporter.9,10,24
In a filing unsealed October 26, Special Assistant U.S. Attorney Dustin Farahnak wrote, as NBC News reported, that prosecutors allege Comey directed staff to speak with New York Times reporter Charlie Savage about accuracy concerns related to a Reuters article, “and thereby illegally transferred classified information.” That alleged direction is distinct from an allegation that Comey personally delivered information to Savage.16
The information dates the alleged conduct to around October 4–5, 2016. The New York Times reported that the court papers do not specify in their public account what national-defense information was allegedly communicated; the cited accounts also describe the individual directed to disclose it as unnamed.9,10,25
The Yahoo story behind the allegations
The charging narrative links two reports published on consecutive days in October 2016. Reuters’s account of the unsealed court documents says prosecutors characterized a Reuters report from the previous day as claiming Yahoo had built custom software to search all incoming emails; the same account describes the surveillance order at issue as requiring Yahoo to search emails tied to an unnamed foreign terrorist group. The public descriptions therefore differ in their stated scope.4
On October 5, The New York Times published Charlie Savage’s article, “Yahoo Said to Have Aided U.S. Email Surveillance by Adapting Spam Filter.” Reuters describes the underlying order in the allegations as requiring Yahoo to search emails tied to an unnamed foreign terrorist group; CBS News reports that the Times article cited two unnamed government officials.4,26
In an unsealed filing, Special Assistant U.S. Attorney Dustin Farahnak wrote that prosecutors allege Comey directed staff to speak with Savage about accuracy concerns over the Reuters report, “and thereby illegally transferred classified information,” NBC News reports. The public descriptions do not specify what information prosecutors say was passed or establish what the reporter received.1,2
What the public record shows—and withholds
The unsealed criminal information is the primary public charging document, but its allegations are not proof that the described conduct occurred. The New York Times reports that the filing accuses Comey of knowingly and willfully causing national-defense information to be communicated to someone not entitled to receive it around October 4–5, 2016.25
A separate prosecution filing, described by NBC News, provides a fuller account of the government’s theory. Special Assistant U.S. Attorney Dustin Farahnak wrote that investigators uncovered evidence Comey directed staff to speak with New York Times reporter Charlie Savage about accuracy concerns related to Reuters’ earlier report, “and thereby illegally transferred classified information.” That is the prosecution’s characterization, not a judicial finding or a public demonstration of what information Savage received.16
The charging language describes the material as “national-defense information”; the separate prosecution account uses “classified information.” The public descriptions do not specify whether those terms refer to the same material or disclose its contents.16,25
The two public accounts differ in detail: the Times describes what the criminal information charges, while Farahnak’s separate filing, as quoted by NBC News, describes the government’s alleged investigative finding and its theory of how the transfer occurred. Neither public description specifies the information allegedly conveyed; USA TODAY likewise reports that the court documents do not say what information was shared.1,2,16,25
The evidence review records the precise contents of the alleged national-defense information as unresolved and says it may be in sealed material. The unsealed descriptions do not establish what the material was or what evidence supports the allegation that it was communicated.1,2
The deadline turns on what can stop the clock
The dispute is whether the October 5, 2026 criminal information preserved charges tied to alleged conduct spanning October 4–5, 2016, or whether prosecutors needed a grand jury indictment within the limitations period. Comey’s lawyers argue that the information did not meet the deadline and that, under the Fifth Amendment, he cannot be tried on an information for these felony charges unless he waives his right to a grand jury indictment. Those are defense arguments, not a judicial ruling. The Justice Department’s position, as reported by NBC News, is that the charges are timely and that filing an information to toll the statute of limitations is a recognized practice.2
The Justice Department’s reported position is that it filed a “waiverless criminal information to toll the statute of limitations” and that multiple federal appeals courts have approved the practice. USA TODAY reported the department’s public explanation; its account does not identify which cases the department relies on or explain how the theory applies to the alleged October 4 conduct as distinct from the alleged October 5 conduct.1,2
The reported dates do not make every alleged act exactly ten years before filing: the alleged period spans October 4 and 5, 2016, while the information was filed on October 5, 2026. NBC News reports that Comey’s lawyers argue both counts rest exclusively on the October 5 disclosure; prosecutors, according to the Associated Press, said evidence presented to a grand jury would concern activities extending into 2017, potentially placing an indictment within the limitations period. That description of the intended grand-jury evidence does not establish that an indictment was returned.2
DOJ’s tolling theory and the limits of the public account
The Justice Department’s stated legal position is that it filed a “waiverless criminal information to toll the statute of limitations.” A DOJ spokesperson told USA TODAY that this practice had been approved by multiple federal appeals courts; Reuters reported the department also called it a “widely recognized practice in federal court.” Those statements describe the government’s rationale, not a decision that the October 5 filing stopped the clock in this case.1,4
Comey’s lawyers take the opposing position: Reuters reports that they asked a judge to dismiss, arguing that a grand jury indictment—not an information—was required within the limitations period. Reuters also reports that prosecutors described the information as a placeholder and that an indictment would still be needed before Comey could face trial. The competing positions concern whether the information preserved the prosecution and whether the case can proceed without a timely indictment; neither party’s argument by itself resolves those questions.4
The claims available for this section do not identify the cases or statutory authorities cited in Comey’s dismissal motion or the Justice Department’s October 23 response, or establish what those filings argued about the authorities’ application. They therefore do not support a case-by-case account of the precedent dispute or a conclusion about whether the D.C. Circuit or Supreme Court has approved this particular tolling procedure.1,2,9,10,22,23
CBS News reported that former prosecutors and defense attorneys Greg Rosen and Michael Bromwich said they had not seen a criminal information used to toll the limitations period in a felony case and considered the maneuver highly unusual. That reported assessment describes their experience; it does not supply the legal authorities cited in the filings or settle the statutory question.17
The reported procedural ruling did not decide the tolling issue: the Associated Press reported that Judge Trevor McFadden declined to rule immediately on dismissal while allowing the Justice Department to pursue a grand jury indictment. The same AP account reported that prosecutor Dustin Farahnak said evidence presented to the grand jury would concern activities extending into 2017; that is the prosecution’s account, not a finding that the alleged conduct occurred or that an indictment was returned.11
Comey denies the charges; earlier inquiries remain partly documented
Comey denied wrongdoing in a video posted on Substack, saying, “I’m still innocent,” and called the prosecution “an appalling abuse of the Department of Justice.” His lawyer Patrick Fitzgerald said Comey “steadfastly maintains his innocence” and that the information “purports to charge Mr. Comey with crimes that he did not commit.” These are the defense’s denial and characterization, not findings about the allegations or the prosecution’s motives.9,17
Fitzgerald said two teams of prosecutors investigated the alleged 2016 disclosure during the first Trump administration and each determined that no charges should be brought. Reuters and NBC News reported his account; that general statement is attributed to the defense.4,16
Separate reporting describes those inquiries more specifically, citing court filings by Comey’s attorneys. The Associated Press reports that John Durham began investigating the disclosure in early 2017 and wrote a classified memo in 2018 recommending no charges. CBS News reports that a second D.C. U.S. Attorney’s Office inquiry, code-named “Tropic Vortex,” closed in February 2020 without charges.11,17,26
The specific dates and outcomes are thus reported through defense court filings, while Fitzgerald’s broader account remains his statement about the inquiries. The cited accounts do not make the underlying investigative records or declination memoranda public, so their full scope, evidence and reasoning cannot be assessed here.11,16,17,26
Two other cases, separate questions
The Virginia case was dismissed after a judge found that prosecutor Lindsey Halligan had been unlawfully appointed, CNBC reports. The material cited here does not establish whether the Justice Department appealed the dismissal.9,14
In a separate case in the Eastern District of North Carolina, a federal grand jury indicted Comey on April 28, 2026, the Justice Department announced. The indictment charges him under 18 U.S.C. § 871(a) with threatening the President and under § 875(c) with transmitting a threat in interstate commerce, based on a May 15, 2025, Instagram post showing “86 47” arranged in seashells. These are allegations, not findings that the post constituted a criminal threat.21
Comey’s lawyers have moved to dismiss the North Carolina charges, arguing that the image was not a true threat and that the prosecution was selective or vindictive. Prosecutors have argued that whether the post was a threat should be decided by a jury, Yahoo reports from court filings; the motions remained unresolved in the cited reporting.7,18
The North Carolina case remains pending, with the arraignment moved from September 30, 2026, to the court’s January 2027 term by Judge Louise W. Flanagan’s September 25 order. The order had set an October 21 trial date if Comey pleaded not guilty; WITN reported that a trial date would follow the January arraignment, while Yahoo, republishing News & Observer reporter Virginia Bridges, reported a February 2027 trial setting. The accounts differ on the trial timing.6,19
The Virginia dismissal and North Carolina indictment concern different charges and proceedings; neither determines the allegations in the D.D.C. information, CNBC reports in its account of the Virginia dismissal and North Carolina indictment.9,21
Political context and a separate employment ruling
The prosecution’s account places the alleged disclosure in a dispute over how to correct a Reuters report about Yahoo’s email scanning: prosecutors say Comey directed staff to speak with New York Times reporter Charlie Savage about accuracy concerns. That explanation is the government’s account of the alleged purpose; the public descriptions do not establish whether the disclosure was lawful or what information was shared.4,16
The wider fairness dispute includes arguments made in Comey’s separate North Carolina case, where his lawyers alleged selective and vindictive prosecution over the seashell post, while U.S. Attorney Ellis Boyle said the allegation of political motivation was “categorically false” and that his office evaluates potential threat prosecutions individually. Those positions concern the North Carolina case; they do not establish motive in this D.D.C. prosecution.18,20
On October 26, Judge Jesse Furman ruled in a separate civil employment case that the Justice Department unlawfully fired Maurene Comey, James Comey’s daughter and a former assistant U.S. attorney, CBS News reports. Furman ordered retroactive reinstatement and back pay through December 20, 2025, when she accepted another job, according to CBS News.13,27
CBS News reports that Furman found the firing violated the Civil Service Reform Act and rejected the department’s argument that the attorney general could remove her without cause. Maurene Comey had alleged that her removal was connected to her father, but the reported basis for Furman’s decision was statutory and procedural; this separate employment ruling is not evidence for or against James Comey’s guilt in the criminal case.12,13,27
The Justice Department said it disagreed with Furman’s ruling and would appeal after a final judgment, CNBC reported. CNBC reported an announced intention to appeal; it did not report that an appeal had been filed. Furman also reserved judgment on Maurene Comey’s First Amendment claim and gave her until November 9 to argue against dismissing it as moot, CNBC reported.12,27
What could still change the case
The next decisive procedural event is a ruling on Comey’s motion to dismiss, followed by any grand-jury action. The Justice Department has been allowed to continue pursuing an indictment, but that permission is not a ruling that the October 5 information tolled the limitations period. [ap-as-syndicated-by-the-jacksonville-journal-courier-on-msn-reports-that-u-s-district-judge-trevor-mcfadden-on-a-friday-]11
There is a date discrepancy in the accounts of the dismissal motion: CNBC reports that Comey’s lawyers filed it on October 9, while the assignment identifies ECF 11 as an October 16 motion. The cited reporting does not resolve that discrepancy; the docket entry itself would be needed to verify the filing date. [cnbc-reports-that-the-doj-filed-the-information-on-october-5-2026-and-asked-judge-trevor-mcfadden-to-seal-it-citing-an-o]10
In a later reported proceeding, the Associated Press said Judge Trevor McFadden deferred an immediate decision on dismissal while allowing prosecutors to pursue an indictment; that account does not give the hearing date. It also reports that prosecutor Dustin Farahnak said evidence presented to a grand jury would concern conduct extending into 2017, a prosecution position that could affect the limitations analysis but does not establish that an indictment was returned. [ap-as-syndicated-by-the-jacksonville-journal-courier-on-msn-reports-that-u-s-district-judge-trevor-mcfadden-on-a-friday-]11
The legal question is whether filing a criminal information without Comey’s waiver of indictment can preserve charges for limitations purposes, or whether the government needed a grand-jury indictment within the relevant period. Comey’s lawyers argue the latter; the Justice Department says the information can toll the deadline and that appeals courts have approved the practice. The accounts cited here do not identify the precise precedents or establish a ruling applying them to this case. [nbc-news-reports-that-comeys-attorneys-argue-both-counts-rest-exclusively-on-the-october-5-2016-alleged-disclosure-exact] [the-doj-told-usa-today-in-response-to-a-request-for-comment-that-it-filed-a-waiverless-criminal-information-to-toll-the-]1,16
The cited accounts establish no specific future briefing or hearing deadline in this case. The order allowing prosecutors to continue seeking an indictment does not decide the tolling question; the motion’s disposition, any indictment or decision not to seek one, and any court ruling on the legal effect of the information would clarify the case’s procedural course. [ap-as-syndicated-by-the-jacksonville-journal-courier-on-msn-reports-that-u-s-district-judge-trevor-mcfadden-on-a-friday-] [dw-reports-that-the-justice-department-filed-a-criminal-information-in-early-october-shortly-before-a-10-year-prosecutio]5,11
The information’s allegations concern conduct around these dates. Prosecutors’ account links the alleged disclosure to staff discussions with the Times about Reuters coverage and the October 5 Yahoo surveillance article.2,16
Comey’s lawyers’ filings, as described by the Associated Press, say John Durham began investigating the disclosure in early 2017 and wrote a classified memo in 2018 recommending no charges.11
CBS News reports, citing defense court filings, that a separate D.C. U.S. Attorney’s Office inquiry, code-named “Tropic Vortex,” closed without charges in February 2020.17
The Justice Department announced a grand-jury indictment in Virginia accusing Comey of making a false statement and obstructing a congressional investigation.3
CNBC’s account of the Virginia case says a judge dismissed it after finding that interim U.S. Attorney Lindsey Halligan had been invalidly appointed.9
The Justice Department announced that a North Carolina grand jury indicted Comey over the “86 47” seashell image, charging threats against the President and transmission of a threat in interstate commerce.21
Prosecutors filed the D.C. criminal information under seal, and Judge Trevor McFadden granted the government’s request to seal it that day, CNBC reports from court records.10
The filing date for Comey’s dismissal motion is described differently: CNBC reports that it was filed October 9, while the assignment identifies ECF 11 as an October 16 motion. The discrepancy is unresolved in the available reporting.9,10
McFadden agreed to unseal the information at Comey’s request. NBC News reported on October 26 that Comey had not been indicted in this case at that point; that report does not establish whether a grand jury acted later.10,16
In a separate employment case, Judge Jesse Furman ruled that the Justice Department had unlawfully fired Maurene Comey; CBS News reports the ruling concerned her employment, not her father’s criminal allegations.13,27
- The precise content of the 'national defense information' allegedly transmitted in October 2016. The criminal information and supporting filings do not specify it in unsealed public portions; it may be sealed.
- Whether the D.C. Circuit or Supreme Court has precedent directly approving tolling of the statute of limitations via a 'waiverless criminal information' in a felony Espionage Act case, as opposed to other contexts.
- The current status of the grand jury investigation referenced by prosecutors. It is unclear if an indictment has been sought or returned since the October 5 information was filed.
- The specific findings of the two prior investigations (Durham 2017-2018 and 'Tropical Vortex' 2019-2020). Defense assertions of declinations are reported, but the internal memos are not public.
- The exact statutory citations and elements of the North Carolina '86 47' charges as filed in the indictment, beyond the DOJ press release's summary.
- Whether an appeal has been formally filed in Maurene Comey's employment case, or if the DOJ's stated intent to appeal remains pending a final judgment.
- What specific information did prosecutors allege was communicated, who were the unnamed individual and any co-conspirators, and what evidence supports the alleged disclosure? Reporting identifies New York Times reporter Charlie Savage separately as the journalist allegedly contacted through staff. [usa-today-reports-that-federal-charging-documents-filed-in-the-u-s-district-court-for-the-district-of-columbia-allege-ja] [nbc-news-quotes-special-assistant-u-s-attorney-dustin-farahnaks-unsealed-filing-as-stating-the-investigation-uncovered-e] [the-new-york-post-reports-that-prosecutors-allege-comey-through-one-and-more-co-conspirators-directed-individual-1-to-di]
- Did a grand jury later return an indictment, and what is the current status of any grand-jury presentation? The reporting cited here establishes no later action. [nbc-news-ryan-j-reilly-and-gary-grumbach-reports-that-federal-prosecutors-charged-former-fbi-director-james-comey-with-t]
- Which appellate decisions does the Justice Department rely on for its tolling theory, and do they apply to this case? The department’s public description does not identify the cases; the defense and the government dispute whether the information preserved the prosecution. [the-doj-told-usa-today-in-response-to-a-request-for-comment-that-it-filed-a-waiverless-criminal-information-to-toll-the-] [nbc-news-reports-that-comeys-attorneys-argue-both-counts-rest-exclusively-on-the-october-5-2016-alleged-disclosure-exact]
- What were the full scope and findings of the Durham and “Tropic Vortex” inquiries, and what records did each review? The reported recommendations and closures are described through defense filings; underlying investigative materials are not public in the cited accounts. [ap-reports-citing-comeys-attorneys-court-filing-that-john-durham-investigated-the-2016-disclosure-beginning-in-early-201] [cbs-news-reports-citing-court-filings-from-comeys-defense-team-that-john-durham-investigated-the-2016-times-article-matt]
- How does the reported 2017 activity relate to the charged conduct and the limitations period? Prosecutor Dustin Farahnak reportedly said grand-jury evidence would concern activities extending into 2017, but the report does not establish that an indictment was returned or how a court would treat that account. [ap-as-syndicated-by-the-jacksonville-journal-courier-on-msn-reports-that-u-s-district-judge-trevor-mcfadden-on-a-friday-]
- 1.
- 2.
- 3.
- 4.
- 5.
- 6.
- 7.
- 8.
- 9.
- 10.Original reportingcnbc.com — DOJ charges ex-FBI Director James Comey in new case - CNBC
- 11.
- 12.
- 13.
- 14.Secondary reportWikipedia — Prosecution of James Comey
- 15.
- 16.
- 17.Secondary reportmsn.com — DOJ takes steps to charge James Comey again - MSN
- 18.
- 19.Secondary reportMSN — Judge grants delay in James Comey case to January 2027
- 20.
- 21.
- 22.Original reportingBBC — Ex-FBI chief James Comey faces federal charges for third time
- 23.Original reportingBBC — Ex-FBI chief James Comey faces federal charges for third time
- 24.Original reportingUPI — Justice Department charges James Comey a third time
- 25.
- 26.Original reportingcbsnews.com — DOJ takes steps to charge James Comey again - CBS News
- 27.