← Front pageReports · Watch · Archive
DRASKER

DRASKER REPORT

published · Updated October 27, 2026

How Paxton’s impeachment trial ended in acquittal

The case grew out of allegations that Paxton intervened on behalf of Nate Paul, an Austin real estate developer. Former senior officials in the attorney general’s office testified for the House, while the defense presented current employees who said they had seen none of the alleged acts.5

The Senate’s public account gives the outcome and broad contours of the case, but not article-by-article vote totals; four articles were held in abeyance.5

KEY POINTS
  • The House adopted impeachment articles in May 2023; the Senate later tried 16 and acquitted Paxton on each, with four additional articles held in abeyance.3,5
  • The House articles alleged that Paxton used his office to aid Nate Paul through actions that included intervening in legal matters and accepting home improvements paid for by Paul.5
  • Former senior officials testified for the House about their allegations; the defense called three current employees who said they had seen none of the alleged acts.5
  • Paxton’s attorney Tony Buzbee argued that the articles were based on incorrect assumptions, were false or did not merit impeachment, and criticized the House process as rushed and secretive.3
  • The Senate reported that no article received a simple majority, but the specific vote totals for each article are not provided in its public account.5
WHAT WE KNOW

On September 16, 2023, the Texas Senate acquitted Attorney General Ken Paxton on all 16 articles of impeachment it tried. The Senate reported that none received even a simple majority, far short of the 21 votes needed to remove him from office.5

The articles alleged that Paxton used the attorney general’s office to help Nate Paul, including through interventions in legal matters and home improvements paid for by Paul. Those were allegations presented in the impeachment case, not findings of the Senate’s judgment.5

The allegations that led to impeachment

The impeachment case concerned Paxton’s relationship with Paul, an Austin real estate developer. In its account of the 16 articles tried, the Senate said they alleged that Paxton directed staff attorneys to misuse the office’s powers to aid Paul. The allegations included improperly issuing grand jury subpoenas, disclosing the identities of law-enforcement officials who searched Paul’s properties, intervening for Paul in civil litigation, and accepting home improvements paid for by Paul.5

House manager Rep. Andrew Murr told senators that the House investigation found Paxton had allegedly appointed outside counsel over Paul’s complaints about law-enforcement searches, issued an opinion intended to prevent foreclosure on Paul’s properties, and retaliated against deputies who raised concerns. Murr also alleged that Paul received unusual access to the attorney general’s office and provided home renovations in return.3

The Senate’s summary says the House case relied on testimony from former senior officials in the attorney general’s office. Some had resigned in October 2020 after reporting allegations of bribery and abuse of office to the FBI; they also alleged they were fired or forced out in violation of whistleblower laws.5

Separately, The Guardian reported that eight of Paxton’s staffers asked the FBI in 2020 to investigate whether he had used his office to help Paul in exchange for home renovations and a job for a woman with whom Paxton was having an affair. The Guardian reported that Paxton and Paul denied the allegations and that Paul was never charged.2

From House action to Senate trial

The Texas Senate’s official Court of Impeachment page dates the House’s adoption of 20 articles to May 27, 2023. A Senate news release says the House approved impeachment in May, with 121 of 150 members voting, and describes the Senate as the body constitutionally empowered to try and remove public officials.3,4

The Senate’s official page says the chamber convened as a high court of impeachment on September 5, 2023. That day, according to a Senate news release, the 16 articles being tried were read and Paxton pleaded not guilty. The release describes the articles as alleging disregard of public duty, misuse of public resources and abuse of public trust, among other charges.3,4

In his opening statement, Paxton’s attorney Tony Buzbee argued that the articles were overwrought, based on incorrect assumptions, false or not grounds for impeachment. Buzbee also criticized a pretrial gag order and described the House process as rushed and secretive.3

The Senate’s account sets out competing testimony: former top officials for the House described their allegations, while three current employees called by the defense testified that they had seen none of the alleged acts. The summary records what each group presented; it does not supply article-by-article findings beyond the acquittals.5

Acquittal and arguments over the process

On September 16, the Senate acquitted Paxton on all 16 articles before it. Four additional articles had been held in abeyance. The Senate reported that no article received a simple majority and that 21 votes were required for removal.5

Lt. Gov. Dan Patrick, who presided, criticized the House process as rushed and called for constitutional amendments to change impeachment rules. Senator Charles Schwertner said the burden of proof beyond a reasonable doubt had not been met; the Senate release notes that he was among 16 senators who voted against every article.5

Senator Paul Bettencourt said he supported motions to dismiss the articles before trial, arguing that a “forgiveness doctrine” in Government Code Section 665.081 applied because the issues were public before Paxton’s most recent election. He also said he supported Patrick’s call to amend the state constitution’s impeachment procedures.6

Bettencourt offered his own estimate of the time spent: he said House members spent less than 10 hours on the articles, with unsworn investigators and no sworn witness testimony or cross-examination, while senators spent more than 700 days of member time on rules, preparation, evidence and voting.6

Earlier cases and unresolved legal questions

Reason reported that a grand jury indicted Paxton in July 2015 on three felony charges related to his solicitation of investments in Servergy while he was a state representative. Reason also reported that, in April 2024, he agreed to restitution and community service in exchange for dismissal of the charges.1

The Senate’s official page lists a judgment in the impeachment case dated September 16, 2023. The Senate news release reports the acquittals and the 21-vote removal threshold, but the available account does not give the tally for each article.4,5

TIMELINE
  1. Reason reported that a grand jury indicted Paxton on three felony charges connected to his solicitation of investments in Servergy while he was a state representative.1

  2. The Guardian reported that eight of Paxton’s staffers asked the FBI to investigate whether he had abused his office to help Paul; it reported that Paxton and Paul denied the allegations.2

  3. According to the Senate’s account of the House case, some former senior officials resigned after reporting allegations of bribery and abuse of office to the FBI.5

  4. The Texas Senate’s official Court of Impeachment page says the House adopted 20 articles of impeachment against Paxton.4

  5. The Senate convened as a high court of impeachment, and Paxton pleaded not guilty when the 16 articles were read, according to the Senate’s official page and news release.3,4

  6. The Senate acquitted Paxton on all 16 articles it tried; four additional articles had been held in abeyance, and no article received a simple majority.5

  7. Reason reported that Paxton agreed to restitution and community service in exchange for dismissal of the 2015 felony charges.1

WHAT WE STILL DON'T KNOW
  • The specific contents of all 20 articles adopted by the House (the Senate tried 16; 4 were held in abeyance). The official 'Court of Impeachment' page notes 20 articles were adopted, but the bundle does not contain the text of H.R. No. 2377.
  • The final vote tally for each of the 16 articles. The Senate news release states no article received a simple majority, but the specific vote counts per article are not provided.
  • The status and details of the four articles that were 'held in abeyance' and later dismissed.
  • The full basis of the 'forgiveness doctrine' (Texas Government Code Section 665.081) argument cited by Senator Bettencourt and whether it was formally adjudicated by the Senate.
  • The current status of the 2020 FBI referral and any related federal investigations into the allegations.
  • The specific 'precedents for impeachment trials of state officials in Texas' referenced in the open questions.
  • The specific contents of all 20 articles adopted by the House (the Senate tried 16; 4 were held in abeyance). The Texas Senate’s official Court of Impeachment page notes that 20 articles were adopted, but the text of H.R. No. 2377 is not included here.
SOURCES
  1. 1.
  2. 2.
  3. 3.
  4. 4.
  5. 5.
  6. 6.