← Front pageReports · Watch · Archive
DRASKER

DRASKER REPORT

published · Updated November 11, 2026

Court Opens Sealed Review of How the Smartmatic Indictment Came About

The company added to the case in October 2025 was left out of the earlier indictment of its own executives, and the judge now wants the government's internal communications about the timing — while warning there may be nothing under the smoke. The review is sealed, and no one has ruled on whether the prosecution itself was retaliatory.2,4

KEY POINTS
  • Judge Kathleen Williams of the U.S. District Court for the Southern District of Florida has granted limited discovery to SGO Corp., the parent of voting-technology company Smartmatic, on its motion to dismiss the superseding indictment against it as a vindictive prosecution, according to Reason's account of the order.4
  • Reason reported that Williams ordered the government to submit for ex parte, in camera review under seal the prosecution memoranda for both indictments; Justice Department communications with former Acting U.S. Attorney Hayden O'Byrne, U.S. Attorney Jason Reding Quiñones and members of the prosecution team concerning the decision and its timing to charge SGO between Jan. 1 and Oct. 16, 2025; and emails from those two prosecutors to SGO's counsel in the same period.4
  • According to Reason's quotation from the order, the court cited five circumstances as 'some evidence': the individual defendants had been charged more than a year before SGO was added; SGO had been cooperating with the government since 2021; SGO was charged during a public shift away from enforcement of the Foreign Corrupt Practices Act, including the Blanche and Bondi memos and Executive Order 14209; SGO had sued people described as President Trump's confederates before it was charged; and Trump had expressed animus toward SGO.4
  • Law & Crime reported that Smartmatic argued it was singled out by Trump and then-Attorney General Pam Bondi for a superseding indictment because of its defamation lawsuits against MAGA allies, despite cooperating with the government, and that it cited the earlier foreign bribery prosecution of its executives, the Justice Department's stated shift away from such cases, Trump's pardons of at least 38 people charged with fraud, corruption or money-laundering offenses, and the Biden administration's 2024 decision not to prosecute the company.2
  • Reason reported that the order does not resolve whether the prosecution was actually vindictive, and that the court expressly noted 'it may well be that no fire will be discovered under all the smoke.' The excerpt Reason described does not state the next procedural step beyond the ordered ex parte submissions and does not address any government objections to discovery.4
WHAT WE KNOW

Judge Kathleen Williams of the U.S. District Court for the Southern District of Florida has granted limited discovery to SGO Corp., the parent of voting-technology company Smartmatic, on its motion to dismiss the superseding indictment against it as a vindictive prosecution, according to Reason's account of the order.4

As described by Law & Crime, the government must produce internal Justice Department documents and communications about its decision to bring charges for a sealed in-chambers review as soon as Nov. 17; Global Investigations Review reported that the Justice Department will have to hand over internal records on its decision to bring the foreign bribery charges.1,2

Global Investigations Review's headline characterized the ruling as a judge finding 'some evidence' of vindictive prosecution; Reason's account, quoting the order, describes the finding more narrowly as 'some evidence' supporting SGO's motion, in a ruling that permits discovery without deciding whether the prosecution was vindictive.1,4

What the order requires

Reason reported that Williams ordered the government to submit for ex parte, in camera review under seal the prosecution memoranda for both indictments; Justice Department communications with former Acting U.S. Attorney Hayden O'Byrne, U.S. Attorney Jason Reding Quiñones and members of the prosecution team concerning the decision and its timing to charge SGO between Jan. 1 and Oct. 16, 2025; and emails from those two prosecutors to SGO's counsel in the same period.4

Law & Crime described the scope somewhat differently, reporting that the order covers all communications — emails, memoranda and correspondence — between Justice Department leadership (the Offices of the Attorney General, Associate Attorney General, Deputy Attorney General and Principal Deputy Attorney General) and O'Byrne, Quiñones and the prosecution team about the decision to charge SGO and its timing over the same January-to-October window, for sealed in-chambers review as soon as Nov. 17.2

The accounts differ in what they include: the version Law & Crime describes identifies the Justice Department leadership offices whose communications are covered but makes no mention of the prosecution memoranda or of emails to SGO's counsel, while the version Reason describes includes those items without naming the four leadership offices. Neither report reproduces the order in full.2,4

The five circumstances the court cited

According to Reason's quotation from the order, the court cited five circumstances as 'some evidence': the individual defendants had been charged more than a year before SGO was added; SGO had been cooperating with the government since 2021; SGO was charged during a public shift away from enforcement of the Foreign Corrupt Practices Act, including the Blanche and Bondi memos and Executive Order 14209; SGO had sued people described as President Trump's confederates before it was charged; and Trump had expressed animus toward SGO.4

Law & Crime reported that Williams reasoned the 'totality of the circumstances' tilts in Smartmatic's favor, citing what she described as President Trump's expressed 'animus' toward Smartmatic, which she wrote 'suggests a possible discriminatory intent that is both personal and political.' A second account carried by Law & Crime on MSN described the finding as limited discovery into the potentially selective or vindictive origins of the superseding indictment, with the same language about animus toward those who 'rigged' the election, including reposted content about Smartmatic.2,3

The order, as Reason quoted it, gives account of SGO's procedural position: SGO was not among the defendants named in the Aug. 8, 2024 six-count indictment of its executives — which brought Foreign Corrupt Practices Act conspiracy and violation counts, money laundering conspiracy, and international laundering counts tied to the May 2016 Philippine elections — and SGO contends the superseding indictment adding it in October 2025 was precipitated by Trump's animus and by the company's defamation suits against Trump's confederates over 2020-election claims.4

What SGO argued

Law & Crime reported that Smartmatic argued it was singled out by Trump and then-Attorney General Pam Bondi for a superseding indictment because of its defamation lawsuits against MAGA allies, despite cooperating with the government, and that it cited the earlier foreign bribery prosecution of its executives, the Justice Department's stated shift away from such cases, Trump's pardons of at least 38 people charged with fraud, corruption or money-laundering offenses, and the Biden administration's 2024 decision not to prosecute the company.2

The same account was carried by Law & Crime on MSN, which reported that Smartmatic cited its cooperation in the 2016 foreign bribery prosecutions of its executives alongside Bondi's shift away from such cases and the pardons.3

What the ruling does not establish

Reason reported that the order does not resolve whether the prosecution was actually vindictive, and that the court expressly noted 'it may well be that no fire will be discovered under all the smoke.' The excerpt Reason described does not state the next procedural step beyond the ordered ex parte submissions and does not address any government objections to discovery.4

Law & Crime likewise reported that the discovery granted is limited, quoting the judge's line that 'it may well be that no fire will be discovered under all the smoke,' and that the report does not describe any ruling on the merits of the vindictive-prosecution defense or specify the next procedural step beyond the production of documents.2

The court's stated basis, as quoted by Law & Crime and Law & Crime on MSN, was a Sixth Circuit vindictive-prosecution case holding that 'there is enough smoke here' to warrant probing how the 'unusual' indictment came about — a threshold for inquiry, in the court's words, not a conclusion about the prosecution's motive.2,3

TIMELINE
  1. A six-count indictment charges SGO executives with Foreign Corrupt Practices Act conspiracy and violation, money laundering conspiracy and international laundering counts related to the May 2016 Philippine elections; SGO itself is not charged, according to Reason's quotation from the order.4

  2. The Biden administration decided not to prosecute the company, a decision Smartmatic cited in its motion, Law & Crime reported.2

  3. The start of the period for which the order requires Justice Department communications about the decision to charge SGO and its timing, as Law & Crime and Reason described the mandate.2

  4. The end of the communications window in the order; SGO contends the superseding indictment adding it in October 2025 was precipitated by President Trump's animus and by its defamation suits, according to Reason's account.2,4

  5. Global Investigations Review publishes a report, headlined by Duncan Randall, that the judge found 'some evidence' of vindictive prosecution and ordered discovery.1

  6. The date by which the government must produce the material for sealed in-chambers review, described by Law & Crime as 'as soon as Nov. 17.'2

WHAT WE STILL DON'T KNOW
  • The full text of the order and the government's response to the discovery request are not among the reports described here; neither account states whether prosecutors opposed the motion or on what grounds.
  • It is not established what happens after the sealed, in-chambers review: no report describes a schedule for the judge's assessment of the produced material or a further hearing on the motion to dismiss.
  • Whether the superseeding indictment proceeds on its current schedule while discovery is reviewed is not addressed in the accounts available.
  • The reports do not say whether the January-to-October 2025 communications window captures all of the decision-making at issue, or why those dates were chosen.
SOURCES
  1. 1.
  2. 2.
  3. 3.
  4. 4.