← Front pageReports · Watch · Archive
DRASKER

DRASKER REPORT

updated · revision 7 · Updated November 2, 2026

Supreme Court turns down California ballot request

The unsigned order gave no explanation, according to the New York Times; the administration had asked the justices to require California to segregate ballots it said were cast by noncitizens.3

KEY POINTS
  • The Supreme Court declined the administration’s Nov. 2 request concerning California ballots that it said were associated with more than 20,000 noncitizen voters.2
  • The California request followed lower-court setbacks: Judge David Carter denied a temporary sequestration order on Oct. 28, and the Ninth Circuit rejected emergency relief before the administration applied to the Supreme Court, SCOTUSblog reported.2
  • The September ruling did not settle whether the final USPS rule was lawful: Justice Kavanaugh said it had a fair prospect of falling within USPS authority, while also concluding that applying it in the 2026 elections would be arbitrary and capricious under the Administrative Procedure Act.4
  • The Nov. 2 order did not explain the justices’ reasoning, and the precise vote count and any private dissents remain unknown.1
WHAT WE KNOW

The Supreme Court declined the Trump administration’s emergency request to make California set aside ballots associated with more than 20,000 registered voters whom the administration contended were noncitizens, SCOTUSblog reported.2

The order, released shortly before 6 p.m. on Nov. 2, was unsigned and had no noted dissents, SCOTUSblog reported.2

A request to set ballots aside

The Trump administration asked the Supreme Court to order California to keep challenged ballots separate until voters’ citizenship could be verified. Solicitor General D. John Sauer argued that federal law bars noncitizens from voting in federal elections and that California would face no undue hardship from holding the ballots aside, SCOTUSblog reported.2

The administration’s request concerned ballots it associated with more than 20,000 registered voters whom it contended were noncitizens; the figure and characterization were the administration’s, as described by SCOTUSblog.2

The request followed a district-court hearing on the same day. David Becker of the Center for Election Innovation & Research said an administration attorney acknowledged that DHS lists of alleged noncitizens likely had a high error rate; Becker also said California election officials described the list as full of errors and said segregating the ballots would be logistically impossible.1

That account comes through Becker’s remarks as reported by The Guardian; the underlying hearing transcript and the officials’ statements are not included here.1

How the California dispute reached the justices

On Oct. 28, U.S. District Judge David Carter rejected the government’s request for a temporary order directing California to sequester ballots of voters described as “likely noncitizens.” SCOTUSblog reported that Carter questioned the credibility of the administration’s allegations about those voters’ citizenship.2

The Ninth Circuit then rejected the administration’s motion for emergency relief, SCOTUSblog reported. The administration’s Supreme Court filing went first to Justice Elena Kagan, who referred it to the full Court.2

On Nov. 2, shortly before 6 p.m. and one day before the midterm elections, the full Court declined the request in a brief unsigned order with no noted dissents, SCOTUSblog reported.2

The New York Times reported that the Court acted within hours of the filing, without first seeking a response or briefing from opposing parties, a procedure the Times described as nearly unheard of for a federal government application.3

The Court did not provide its reasoning, The Guardian reported. The available reporting notes no public dissents, but does not establish the precise vote or whether any private dissents existed.1,3

The earlier fight over Postal Service rules

The mail-ballot litigation began with Executive Order 14399, signed by President Donald Trump on March 31. The order directed the executive branch to develop state citizenship lists and USPS to conduct rulemaking on mail and absentee ballots, including official-election-mail markings, unique barcodes and state-specific participation lists; it conditioned implementation on applicable law.5

The order’s USPS provisions called for agency rulemaking; they were not themselves a final postal regulation, according to the order’s description and the Supreme Court’s account.5,6

On Aug. 24, the Supreme Court stayed an earlier injunction in a case challenging the executive order before agencies had completed their work. The Court focused on standing and ripeness, concluding that the states’ claimed injuries depended on how future agency actions would be implemented.6

The Court expressly said that its August ruling did not mean later measures implementing the order would necessarily be lawful.6,7

It also distinguished an instruction to propose a rule from a proposed or final rule, and said a final rule could be challenged if it caused concrete harm.6

USPS published its final rules on Aug. 21, requiring states to provide information about intended mail-ballot recipients and specifying election-mail designs and barcodes, according to the Daily Signal.4

What the September opinions did—and did not—decide

In its September order, the Supreme Court said the government was unlikely to succeed on the merits, according to the Daily Signal.4

Justice Brett Kavanaugh wrote separately that the final rule had “at least a fair prospect” of falling within USPS’s statutory authority, but that applying it in the 2026 elections would be arbitrary and capricious under the Administrative Procedure Act.4

Justice Samuel Alito dissented, with Justice Clarence Thomas concurring, arguing that the plaintiff states and courts bore substantial blame for the timing of the rule.4

The parties also presented competing accounts of the election-calendar consequences. The administration argued that denying a stay would cause irreparable harm because many states would mail ballots that week; states and voting-rights challengers argued that imposing new federal requirements so close to voting would cause legal and logistical harms.4,9

The September emergency ruling left the injunction in place, but the legality of the final USPS rule remained unresolved.6,9

Two disputes, and the questions still open

The California application concerned whether the state should set aside ballots associated with voters the administration identified as likely noncitizens. The September USPS case concerned whether a new federal postal rule could operate during the election period while litigation proceeded.2,7

In the California dispute, the Supreme Court’s brief order offered no stated rationale; in the USPS case, the September ruling addressed the request to stay a preliminary injunction rather than finally deciding all statutory and constitutional issues.1,7

The exact error rate of the DHS list and the specific logistical obstacles California officials cited are not established in the material available for this report.1

The current status of the underlying merits litigation in both disputes is also not established here.6,9

TIMELINE
  1. President Donald Trump signed Executive Order 14399, directing citizenship-list work and USPS rulemaking on mail-ballot procedures.5

  2. USPS published final rules on information for intended mail-ballot recipients and on election-mail designs and barcodes, according to the Daily Signal.4

  3. The Supreme Court stayed an earlier injunction, concluding that the states’ pre-implementation challenge faced standing and ripeness problems at that stage.6

  4. A new preliminary injunction was entered after the USPS final rule, according to the Supreme Court’s account of the subsequent proceedings.6,7

  5. The government withdrew its earlier stay application and filed a new one challenging the September 4 injunction; the Supreme Court ordered responses by Sept. 9.7,8

  6. U.S. District Judge David Carter denied the government’s request for a temporary order to sequester California ballots associated with voters described as likely noncitizens, SCOTUSblog reported.2

  7. The Supreme Court declined the administration’s request concerning California ballots in a brief unsigned order released shortly before 6 p.m., with no noted dissents, SCOTUSblog reported.2

WHAT WE STILL DON'T KNOW
  • The exact error rate and specific logistical hurdles cited by California election officials regarding the DHS list of alleged noncitizens.
  • The full legal reasoning behind the Ninth Circuit's September 4 ruling that using the SAVE database would illegally disclose personal data, beyond the summary provided in secondary reports.
  • The specific 'novel design requirements' and 'specific administrative lists' referenced in the Mod Podge Rocks report on the blocked USPS rule, as no primary rule text is provided.
  • Whether any states changed their ballot mailing procedures or designs in response to the proposed USPS rule between its publication and the injunction.
  • The precise vote count and any private dissents in the Supreme Court's November 2 order, as only public dissents are noted.
  • The current status of the underlying merits litigation on both the USPS rule and the California ballot challenge following the Supreme Court's emergency denials.
SOURCES
  1. 1.
  2. 2.
  3. 3.
  4. 4.
  5. 5.
  6. 6.
  7. 7.
  8. 8.
  9. 9.
REVISION HISTORY
  • Revision 7 · November 2, 2026 · material update
  • Revision 6 · October 27, 2026 · material update
  • Revision 5 · October 23, 2026 · material update
  • Revision 4 · October 21, 2026 · material update
  • Revision 3 · October 21, 2026 · material update
  • Revision 2 · October 2, 2026 · material update
  • Revision 1 · September 5, 2026