← Front pageReports · Watch · Archive
DRASKER

DRASKER REPORT

updated · revision 12 · Updated November 5, 2026

Why Pennsylvania and the CDC count measles deaths differently

Pennsylvania’s six-death tally uses a state definition that can include a death occurring within 30 days of measles symptoms when the person has a positive test and no unrelated cause is identified; the CDC’s reported standard relies on measles being listed as the underlying cause on the death certificate.2

The difference is consequential in the first two infant cases: the coroner attributed one death to a traumatic spleen injury and the other to measles, while the exact mechanism of the first injury remains unexplained.13,14,15,16

KEY POINTS
  • Pennsylvania confirmed six measles-associated deaths by Nov. 4; the CDC’s Oct. 29 national tally listed four, using a narrower underlying-cause standard than Pennsylvania’s state definition.1,2
  • The coroner said the first newborn had active measles acquired before birth but died from a traumatic spleen laceration; he said measles caused the death of the second infant, who had a fatal genetic disorder and was in palliative care.13,14,15,16
  • Earlier accounts called the Franklin County woman’s death a possible sixth; by Nov. 4, The Inquirer reported that the state had not found that case met its definition and was still investigating it, while the newly confirmed Jefferson County death was the sixth.1,2
  • The coroner said the precise mechanism of the newborn’s spleen injury remained unexplained.13,14
WHAT WE KNOW

Pennsylvania health officials confirmed a sixth measles-associated death on Nov. 4, 2026, involving an unvaccinated Jefferson County resident who tested positive for measles; the state released no further details, citing privacy laws.1

The CDC’s Oct. 29 dashboard listed four deaths nationally, while Pennsylvania had confirmed six, a gap that reflects different definitions rather than a single shared counting rule.2

A rising state count and a different federal tally

Pennsylvania’s count rose from five measles-associated deaths in late September and early October to six. The Pennsylvania Department of Health said on Sept. 30 that an unvaccinated Lancaster County resident who tested positive had died, and the state described that as its fifth measles-associated death of 2026.10

On Nov. 4, Pennsylvania health officials confirmed a sixth death, an unvaccinated Jefferson County resident who tested positive for measles. The state released no further details, citing privacy laws.1

The counts cannot be read as though the state and federal authorities were applying the same definition. The Epoch Times described Pennsylvania’s standard as counting a death within 30 days of symptom onset in a person with a positive laboratory test, provided the death was not due to an unrelated cause. It described the CDC’s standard as requiring measles to be listed as the underlying cause on the death certificate.2

The figures also changed over time. The Pennsylvania Department of Health’s Oct. 9 update listed five previously confirmed measles-associated deaths. The Hill reported that the CDC added a third national death after verification by the National Center for Health Statistics that measles was the underlying cause. By Oct. 29, the CDC dashboard listed four deaths; Pennsylvania’s count was six by Nov. 4.2,4,8

The first two infant deaths were not alike

Pennsylvania announced two measles-associated deaths on Aug. 25 and said both people were unvaccinated. The public accounts describe two infants, but their medical circumstances and the coroner’s conclusions differed.12

For the first newborn, the mother’s family told The Atlantic that she became severely ill immediately before delivery, developing a fever of 102°F and receiving IV fluids for dehydration on Aug. 13; she went into labor the following day. The newborn was delivered with a pulse but was not breathing, and resuscitation was unsuccessful.17

Postmortem testing of the newborn’s lung tissue showed active measles infection acquired before birth. Lancaster County Coroner Stephen Diamantoni said the cause of death was a lacerated spleen, and that the forensic pathologist considered the rupture traumatic rather than caused by measles; he said the spleen was neither enlarged nor inflamed.13,14

The coroner said measles appeared in Part II of the death certificate, which records significant conditions contributing to death but outside the direct causal sequence producing the underlying cause. He said the pathologist did not consider the case a measles death.13,14

The parents told The Atlantic they initially thought the mother’s measles had contributed to the loss because their midwife had told them so, and said they had not heard about the spleen rupture until the reporter raised the coroner’s public statements. The parents’ account does not resolve how the injury occurred.13,14,17

In the second case, Diamantoni identified a six-week-old girl with Amish lethal microcephaly, a rare genetic neurologic disorder, who had received palliative care from birth. He said measles caused her death. The disorder was part of the child’s medical context; it does not change the coroner’s stated causal conclusion.15,16

Why the first case sits at the boundary of the definitions

Pennsylvania’s use of “measles-associated” is broader than a finding that measles directly caused death: the state has explained that it may use the term when measles is present even if a coroner does not identify it as the immediate cause.12

That distinction describes the first newborn’s case. The state counted the child as measles-associated because the child had measles; the coroner said the fatal spleen rupture was traumatic and was not attributed to measles. In the second infant’s case, the coroner said measles itself caused the death.12,13,15

The infants’ vaccination status also requires context. Pennsylvania said both people were unvaccinated, but CDC guidance does not recommend measles vaccine for infants younger than six months; its routine schedule begins at 12 to 15 months, with earlier vaccination from six months possible in specified higher-risk circumstances. A newborn and a six-week-old could not have been vaccinated under that guidance.12,18

The first newborn’s mother was unvaccinated, according to the family, and became acutely ill with measles shortly before delivery. That account provides context for the infant’s congenital infection, while the coroner’s stated cause of death remains the spleen injury.13,14,17

The Franklin County case and shifting descriptions

In October, the Franklin County Coroner’s Office reported a 39-year-old woman’s death after a recent measles diagnosis and said the case met Pennsylvania’s definition. The office cited several underlying conditions and withheld further details, including vaccination status.8

The coroner’s office spokesperson told NBC News that the primary cause was a probable acute cardiac event due to possible complications of measles. The Pennsylvania Department of Health said it was reviewing the reported death under its definition, which requires death within 30 days of symptom onset, clinical measles and a positive laboratory test, with no unrelated cause.8

Some earlier coverage described the Franklin County death as a sixth death, reflecting the coroner’s account and the state’s earlier five-death tally. By Nov. 4, The Epoch Times reported that the Department of Health had not accepted the coroner’s determination that the woman’s death met the state definition; The Inquirer reported that the state was still investigating a seventh reported death and had not found a case that fit its definition.1,2,9

The Nov. 4 coverage therefore identifies the new Jefferson County death as Pennsylvania’s sixth confirmed measles-associated death while describing the Franklin County matter as still under investigation. The Department of Health’s final determination on that case is not included in the reporting cited here.1

A federal review process and a public dispute

The CDC’s approach shifted toward mortality data from the National Center for Health Statistics rather than relying on state health department reports, Reuters reported. The same account said the CDC was working with state epidemiologists on a standard definition and that its tally could change as reviews were completed.7

HHS said the CDC was working with the Council of State and Territorial Epidemiologists to develop a standardized definition for measles deaths. The Hill reported that the CDC’s addition of a third national death followed National Center for Health Statistics verification that measles was the underlying cause.4

Pennsylvania Governor Josh Shapiro and Health Secretary Robert F. Kennedy Jr. publicly disagreed over how measles deaths should be defined, Reuters reported. The Hill reported that Shapiro accused Kennedy in August of spreading misinformation that contributed to declining vaccination rates; Kennedy denied doing so and accused Shapiro of politicizing the outbreak.4,7

The Guardian, citing Reuters, reported that Kennedy asked senior CDC officials in September to remove a measles death from the official tally after questioning whether measles contributed to it. That reported account concerns the federal counting process; it does not establish the status of each Pennsylvania case in the CDC’s review.6

Pennsylvania sought CDC emergency assistance in September and, according to The Guardian, conditioned its request on the CDC publicly recognizing the state’s reported deaths. The Guardian reported that the state said it could rescind the request if the CDC could not communicate those deaths transparently.11

The outbreak’s scale and response

Pennsylvania’s outbreak expanded during the same period. The state had confirmed 731 cases across 38 counties as of Sept. 17, according to The Guardian; PennLive reported 1,426 cases across 44 counties as of Oct. 31, and Star News, citing NBC10 and the state Department of Health, reported 1,467 across 45 counties by Nov. 4.3,5,11

The Department of Health’s reported county breakdown for the six deaths was two residents of Jefferson County, three of Lancaster County and one of Mifflin County. The same report said two Lancaster County infants were too young for vaccination under current recommendations.2

Pennsylvania providers administered more than 61,000 MMR doses in October, more than double a typical month, according to The Epoch Times’ account of state health officials. The report also said the state had not released further details about the newly confirmed Jefferson County death because of privacy laws.1,2

The CDC sent an Epidemic Intelligence Service officer to assist with the Pennsylvania response; PennLive reported that the officer arrived Oct. 16 to help with epidemiological modeling through Nov. 6.5

TIMELINE
  1. Pennsylvania announced two measles-associated deaths and said both individuals were unvaccinated.12

  2. Pennsylvania was seeking CDC emergency assistance as the outbreak reached 731 confirmed cases across 38 counties and four measles-associated deaths, according to The Guardian.11

  3. The Pennsylvania Department of Health said an unvaccinated Lancaster County resident who tested positive for measles had died, calling it the state’s fifth measles-associated death of 2026.10

  4. The Franklin County Coroner’s Office reported that a 39-year-old woman who died on Oct. 10 had a recent measles diagnosis and that the case met Pennsylvania’s definition; the state said it was reviewing the report.8

  5. A CDC Epidemic Intelligence Service officer arrived to assist Pennsylvania with epidemiological modeling through Nov. 6, PennLive reported.5

  6. Pennsylvania health officials confirmed a sixth measles-associated death, involving an unvaccinated Jefferson County resident who tested positive for measles, and released no further details citing privacy laws.1

WHAT WE STILL DON'T KNOW
  • What caused the traumatic spleen injury in the first newborn? The coroner identified it but the mechanism remains unexplained.
  • Will the coroner's final documentation change any part of the first case's cause-of-death assessment? The process is ongoing.
  • Has the Pennsylvania Department of Health completed its review of the Franklin County coroner's reported death (the potential seventh), and if so, what was the determination?
  • What is the precise timeline and official justification for the CDC's shift to using National Center for Health Statistics data for measles death counts?
  • As of the latest data, how many of Pennsylvania's six confirmed measles-associated deaths have been verified by the CDC's NCHS process and included in its national tally?
  • What is the current, detailed breakdown (age, county, vaccination status) of all six confirmed Pennsylvania measles-associated deaths?
SOURCES
  1. 1.
  2. 2.
  3. 3.
  4. 4.
  5. 5.
  6. 6.
  7. 7.
  8. 8.
  9. 9.
  10. 10.
  11. 11.
  12. 12.
  13. 13.
  14. 14.
  15. 15.
  16. 16.
  17. 17.
  18. 18.
REVISION HISTORY
  • Revision 12 · November 5, 2026 · material update
  • Revision 11 · November 2, 2026 · material update
  • Revision 10 · October 26, 2026 · material update
  • Revision 9 · October 23, 2026 · material update
  • Revision 8 · October 23, 2026 · material update
  • Revision 7 · October 23, 2026 · material update
  • Revision 6 · October 21, 2026 · material update
  • Revision 5 · October 21, 2026 · material update
  • Revision 4 · October 13, 2026 · material update
  • Revision 3 · October 6, 2026 · material update
  • Revision 2 · October 2, 2026 · material update
  • Revision 1 · September 5, 2026