← Front pageReports · Watch · Archive
DRASKER

DRASKER REPORT

published · Updated November 3, 2026

Why the judge dismissed the case against two former FBI officials

The case began with a criminal complaint, not a grand jury indictment. That distinction leaves prosecutors a possible route to seek charges again, but the dismissal does not establish whether they will do so.1,3

KEY POINTS
  • Faruqui dismissed the complaint because prosecutors failed to show probable cause that Floris and Benavides knowingly made false statements; he said some statements were not false and others could reflect honest mistakes of memory.3
  • The prosecution proceeded by criminal complaint rather than grand jury indictment, and Faruqui said the case had to get to a grand jury.1,4
  • The Justice Department said it disagreed with the dismissal and was evaluating its options; the department did not provide further comment to CNBC on the ongoing investigation.1,2
  • The Guardian reported that Faruqui called the prosecution “weaponization” in court. Floris’s and Benavides’s attorneys separately characterized the charges as politically motivated and “political theater.”1,3
  • Prosecutors could seek a grand jury’s approval for charges, but the available accounts do not establish whether the dismissal was with prejudice or what precise evidence the government presented.3
WHAT WE KNOW

U.S. Magistrate Judge Zia Faruqui dismissed the criminal complaint against former FBI officials Nikki Floris and Bradley Benavides, saying prosecutors had not shown probable cause that they knowingly made false statements to lawmakers about their knowledge of the Hunter Biden laptop investigation.1,3

The judge’s stated reason for dismissal

Faruqui dismissed the complaint after concluding that prosecutors had not shown probable cause that Floris and Benavides knowingly made false statements to Congress. The Guardian reported his explanation that some of the statements were not actually false, while others could be explained by honest mistakes of memory.3

The ruling addresses the threshold prosecutors had to meet for the complaint before Faruqui; it is not described in the available reporting as a finding that the officials’ testimony was truthful in every respect. The exact statements at issue, the evidence prosecutors offered about them, and the contents of the judge’s written findings are not provided in the cited accounts.3

A complaint, not an indictment

The Justice Department brought the case by criminal complaint rather than by grand jury indictment. At a hearing, Faruqui said prosecutors had filed an unsigned complaint without judicial approval and that a superseding complaint would require a judicial finding of probable cause; he described charging past conduct by complaint rather than indictment as unusual and said the case “has to get to a grand jury.”1,4

CNBC reported that the original complaint was made public the Friday before the Oct. 27 hearing and accused the officials of false statements to the House Judiciary Committee in 2023. CNBC also reported that both were arrested that Friday and released.4

A criminal complaint is not the same procedural step as a grand jury indictment. NBC News reported that charges could theoretically be revived if the Justice Department persuades a federal grand jury to find probable cause; The Guardian likewise reported that prosecutors could present evidence to a grand jury. Neither account establishes that prosecutors will seek an indictment.1,3

The case’s procedural lead-up

On Oct. 27, 2026, Faruqui refused to sign a superseding criminal complaint that prosecutors had filed overnight and that would have added an obstruction charge, CNBC reported. At the hearing, Faruqui said prosecutors would first need a judicial finding of probable cause for such a complaint.4

Floris’s attorneys called that unsigned, unsworn proposed complaint legally deficient and a serious abuse of the criminal charging process. Those were the defense’s characterizations, not findings by the judge.4

NBC News reported that an FBI agent testified at a preliminary hearing that he worried the investigation directed by Kash Patel would be viewed as political, and acknowledged that prosecutor Carlton Davis had called the complaint flawed in a phone call.1

Responses and the possibility of another case

The Justice Department said it disagreed with Faruqui’s decision and was evaluating all options. In a statement quoted by NBC News, it gave no further account of its next steps.1

Floris’s and Benavides’s attorneys called the charges politically motivated and “political theater,” respectively. These statements describe the defense position and do not establish the judge’s rationale for dismissing the complaint.1

The Guardian reported that Faruqui described the prosecution as “weaponization” in court and suggested the charges had been brought 10 days before the midterm elections. The Guardian’s account does not quote his written findings.3

The reporting leaves open whether the dismissal was with prejudice, whether the Justice Department will ask a grand jury to consider charges, and what evidence it presented on the alleged false statements. Those points matter to the prospects and scope of any further prosecution.1,3

TIMELINE
  1. The officials were accused of making false statements to the House Judiciary Committee about their involvement in investigations of Hunter Biden.4

  2. CNBC reported that prosecutors unveiled the allegations using a criminal complaint rather than a grand jury indictment.2

  3. Faruqui refused to sign a superseding complaint filed overnight that would have added an obstruction charge, CNBC reported.4

  4. Faruqui dismissed the criminal complaint against Floris and Benavides.1

WHAT WE STILL DON'T KNOW
  • Was the dismissal formally 'with prejudice' or 'without prejudice'? This determines the DOJ's ability to refile directly.
  • What specific evidence did the DOJ present to allege the statements were false, and what specific statements by Floris and Benavides are at issue?
  • What are the exact contents of Judge Faruqui's written order or findings of fact?
  • Did Judge Faruqui make a finding on the merits regarding the officials' conduct, or only on the legal insufficiency of the charging document?
  • What is the specific legal standard for 'probable cause' in a criminal complaint, and how did the government's evidence fail to meet it according to the judge?
  • What is the procedural path and likelihood for the DOJ to present the case to a grand jury following this dismissal?
SOURCES
  1. 1.
  2. 2.
  3. 3.
  4. 4.