Faruqui dismisses charges against former FBI officials
The case began with a criminal complaint alleging that Floris and Benavides lied to the House Judiciary Committee about their roles in the FBI’s Foreign Influence Task Force and its Hunter Biden investigations.3
The dismissal followed a separate dispute over prosecutors’ attempt to add an obstruction charge, which Faruqui declined to approve.4
- Faruqui dismissed the charges after finding prosecutors had not established probable cause that Floris and Benavides knowingly lied; he said some statements were not false and others could reflect mistakes of memory.1
- The complaint alleged that the officials’ 2023 congressional testimony misrepresented their roles in the Foreign Influence Task Force and FBI investigations involving Hunter Biden.3
- Before the dismissal, Faruqui declined to sign a proposed superseding complaint adding obstruction, criticizing prosecutors for filing it overnight without judicial approval.4
- The Justice Department said it disagreed with the dismissal and was evaluating its options; Floris’s and Benavides’s lawyers rejected the accusations and described them as politically motivated.3
- The Justice Department has not said whether it will seek an indictment, and Kash Patel has not identified the specific materials he says contradict the former officials’ testimony.2,5
Magistrate Judge Zia Faruqui dismissed criminal charges against former FBI officials Nikki Floris and Bradley Benavides on Nov. 2, 2026, finding prosecutors had not shown probable cause that they knowingly made false statements to Congress about the bureau’s Hunter Biden laptop investigation.1
Faruqui said some statements were not false and others could be explained by honest mistakes of memory.1
The allegations and the court’s ruling
The criminal complaint alleged that Floris and Benavides lied when they testified before the House Judiciary Committee in 2023 about their roles in the Foreign Influence Task Force and in FBI investigations concerning Hunter Biden. Those are allegations in the complaint, not findings that the officials lied.3
On Nov. 2, 2026, Faruqui dismissed the charges, finding prosecutors had failed to show probable cause that the two officials knowingly made false statements. He said some statements were not actually false and that others could be attributed to honest mistakes of memory.1
The Guardian’s account of Faruqui’s ruling describes his probable-cause finding and his assessment of particular statements, but does not provide the full text of the testimony or a statement-by-statement account of the evidence prosecutors presented.1
How the case developed
CNBC reported that the case was brought by criminal complaint on Oct. 20 over conduct from 2023. At a preliminary hearing on the original complaint, Faruqui said, “This has to get to a grand jury”; CNBC noted that prosecutors generally must obtain an indictment within 30 days of an arrest.4
In a separate procedural dispute, Faruqui refused to sign a superseding criminal complaint that would have added an obstruction charge. CNBC reported that he criticized prosecutors for filing it overnight without judicial approval.4
The Guardian reported that Faruqui suggested prosecutors had purposefully brought the charges 10 days before the midterm elections. At the hearing, he said, “What has transpired here cannot be described as anything other than weaponization.”1
The disputed account of the investigation
FBI Director Kash Patel said in a social media post that Floris and Benavides testified the Foreign Influence Task Force was not involved in the Hunter Biden investigations. Patel said documentary evidence, contemporaneous communications and witness accounts contradicted their testimony; he did not identify those materials in the account reported by ZeroHedge.2
Prosecutors, as described by Fox News in a report cited by ZeroHedge, alleged that Benavides told Congress he learned about the laptop story in a particular way, while the Justice Department had evidence he discussed it with others inside the FBI. The same account said prosecutors alleged Floris discussed Hunter Biden with task force members despite testifying otherwise; these allegations are not established by the court ruling described here.2,5
The Guardian reported that an unnamed FBI agent testified the investigation began after the president’s July primetime address on election security, following which Patel tasked the Kansas City field office with scrutinizing Floris. That account is based on the agent’s testimony, not a finding in Faruqui’s ruling.1
Responses and what remains in play
The Justice Department said it disagreed with Faruqui’s decision and was “evaluating all options.” Floris’s attorneys called the charges a “politically-motivated smear campaign”; Benavides’s attorneys called the accusations “political theater” and said he was innocent.3
NBC News reported that an FBI agent testified at a preliminary hearing that he was concerned the investigation, directed by Patel, would be viewed as political, and acknowledged that prosecutor Carlton Davis had called the complaint flawed. The reported testimony describes the agent’s views and does not itself resolve the allegations against Floris or Benavides.3
The Justice Department said it was evaluating its options after the dismissal, but the department’s statement did not specify whether it would seek a grand jury indictment.3
The Guardian reported Faruqui’s criticism of the timing of the charges; the supplied account does not include a formal, on-the-record response from the U.S. Attorney’s office to that criticism.1
Floris and Benavides testified before the House Judiciary Committee; the complaint later alleged they lied about their roles in the task force and FBI investigations concerning Hunter Biden.3
CNBC reported that prosecutors brought the case by criminal complaint over conduct from 2023.4
CNBC reported that Faruqui declined to sign a superseding complaint adding an obstruction charge, criticizing prosecutors for filing it overnight without judicial approval.4
Faruqui dismissed the charges after finding prosecutors had not shown probable cause that Floris and Benavides knowingly made false statements.1
- The specific statutory citations (beyond 'lying to Congress') in the original or superseding criminal complaints.
- The precise nature of the 'documentary evidence, contemporaneous communications, and witness accounts' that Director Patel alleges contradict the defendants' testimony.
- Whether the Justice Department will seek a grand jury indictment following the dismissal, and if so, the timeline.
- The full, verbatim statements the defendants are alleged to have made falsely, as detailed in the charging documents.
- The specific evidence prosecutors cited to support the obstruction charge that Judge Faruqui refused to sign.
- Any formal, on-the-record response from the U.S. Attorney's office (beyond the DOJ statement) to the judge's criticism of the prosecution's timing.
- The specific statutory citations in the original or superseding criminal complaints.
- The precise documentary evidence, contemporaneous communications and witness accounts Patel says contradict the officials’ testimony.
- Whether the Justice Department will seek a grand jury indictment after the dismissal, and on what timeline.
- The full statements the officials are alleged to have made falsely, as set out in the charging documents.
- The evidence prosecutors cited to support the obstruction charge Faruqui declined to approve.
- Whether the U.S. Attorney’s office will respond formally to the judge’s criticism of the prosecution’s timing.
- 1.
- 2.
- 3.Original reportingNBC News — BREAKING | Judge dismisses all charges against FBI agents.
- 4.
- 5.