Judge dismisses charges over broken playground swing
Reason reports that the judge found the girls caused the damage but ruled it an accident, not an intentional act; the criminal-mischief charges were dismissed on Aug. 20, 2026, according to Law News.1,2
- Reason reports the sisters were charged after a swing broke during play at a Springdale park, where several children were twisting its chains.2
- The judge found the girls caused the damage but ruled it accidental, not an intentional act, and found them not guilty, Reason reports.2
- Katie Huss said five or six children were involved but police focused on her daughters; she also said she was not shown surveillance footage or other evidence before the hearing.2
- Reason reports the borough divided an approximately $295 repair bill among five children at roughly $59 each; Katie Huss said she withheld payment pending proof of intent, according to Law News.1,2
Two sisters, ages 10 and 12, were charged with criminal mischief after a playground swing broke at Veterans Memorial Park in Springdale, Pennsylvania, while they and other children twisted its chains to spin, Reason reports.2
A judge later found the damage accidental rather than intentional and found the girls not guilty, Reason reports.2
The incident and charges
Reason reports that the sisters, ages 10 and 12, were charged with criminal mischief after a swing broke at Veterans Memorial Park in Springdale, Pennsylvania. The girls and several other children were twisting the swing’s chains to spin.2
Reason reports that criminal-mischief charges were filed against the two sisters after the swing broke during play.2
Repair costs and the family’s account
Law News, citing TribLive, reports that repairs cost approximately $295 and that Springdale Borough divided the amount among five children at roughly $59 each. Three families paid, while the girls’ mother, Katie Huss, refused pending proof of intent.1
Huss said five or six children were involved but police focused on her daughters, according to Reason. She also said police or the borough did not show her surveillance video or other evidence before the hearing.2
Huss said five or six children were involved, according to Reason.2
The judge’s ruling
Reason reports that the judge found the girls caused the damage but ruled it was an accident rather than an intentional act, and found them not guilty.2
Law News reports that the charges were dismissed on Aug. 20, 2026, after the judge found accidental damage rather than intentional criminal mischief under Pennsylvania crime code 3304, which requires proof of intent.1
Reason reports that the judge found the damage accidental rather than intentional and found the girls not guilty; Law News reports that the charges were dismissed on Aug. 20, 2026.1,2
What remains unclear
Huss said police or the borough did not show her surveillance footage or other evidence before the hearing, according to Reason.2
Huss said five or six children were involved but police focused on her daughters, according to Reason.2
- The specific, on-record legal basis for the initial decision to file criminal charges against only these two children, as opposed to others involved.
- Whether surveillance footage or other concrete evidence of intent existed and was reviewed by the judge, beyond the mother's account of not being shown it.
- The official policy or precedent in Springdale Borough or Pennsylvania for pursuing criminal charges versus civil restitution for minor property damage caused by juveniles.
- The identities and accounts of the other children reportedly involved and their families, particularly the three who allegedly paid their share.
- The condition and age of the swing equipment prior to the incident, which could inform whether the damage was a foreseeable result of normal play.
- Any formal response or statement from the Springdale Borough police department regarding their investigation and charging decisions.
- 1.
- 2.Original reportingReason — Brickbat: Swing, Swing