← Front pageReports · Watch · Archive
DRASKER

DRASKER REPORT

published · Updated November 1, 2026

What the California election subpoenas seek

The Chronicle says the subpoena documents set appearances for Nov. 4 in Los Angeles County and Nov. 18 in Orange County.2

County officials described differing response statuses, while a federal judge separately criticized the Justice Department's treatment of local election officials.2

KEY POINTS
  • The Chronicle says subpoenas went to officials in at least four California counties and sought unredacted voter records, including registration, address, voting history and citizenship status.2
  • The Chronicle says the subpoenas were part of criminal investigations into alleged noncitizen voting, and set appearances for Nov. 4 in Los Angeles County and Nov. 18 in Orange County.2
  • Orange County Registrar Bob Page said his office complied with three September subpoenas and planned to provide responsive documents for a later subpoena; a Santa Clara County spokesperson said the registrar received two federal subpoenas in September.2
  • Separately, ABC News reported that Justice Department letters to officials in multiple states warned of criminal penalties for failing to preserve election records; the available account does not establish whether those letters and the California subpoenas are parts of one coordinated inquiry.1
  • U.S. District Judge David O. Carter warned a federal prosecutor to stop threatening local election officials and characterized the department's actions as a pattern of attempted election interference, the Chronicle reported.2
WHAT WE KNOW

The San Francisco Chronicle, citing subpoenas obtained by its reporters and statements from county officials, says the Justice Department subpoenaed election officials in Los Angeles, Orange, Santa Clara and San Diego counties in investigations into possible noncitizen voting.2

The Chronicle says the documents seek unredacted voter information and ask for material that “tends to indicate an alien has voted in a federal election.”2

Two related developments, with different stated purposes

ABC News reported, based on copies of letters it obtained, that the Justice Department warned election officials in multiple states about preserving election records under federal law.1

ABC News described Acting Deputy Attorney General Trent McCotter's letter, sent Thursday to state election leaders, as a reminder to preserve ballots, pollbooks, precinct sign-in sheets and other election materials. The letter said willful noncompliance could bring up to a year in prison and a $1,000 fine.1

The California subpoenas are a separate documented development: the Chronicle says they sought voter information in criminal investigations into alleged noncitizen voting. The available reporting suggests contextual overlap with the records-preservation letters but does not establish that the two actions are a single inquiry.1,2

What the California subpoenas request

The Chronicle reported that subpoenas went to local election officials in at least four counties: Los Angeles, Orange, Santa Clara and San Diego. It said the requests included unredacted voter registration, address, voting-history and citizenship-status information.2

In its review of the documents, the Chronicle said the subpoenas were issued as part of criminal investigations into alleged fraudulent voting by noncitizens and sought information that “tends to indicate an alien has voted in a federal election.” It reported appearance dates of Nov. 4 in Los Angeles County and Nov. 18 in Orange County.2

The reporting describes the subpoenas' stated investigative subject and the records sought; it does not establish from the information available here whether the Justice Department regards the county subpoenas as one coordinated wider inquiry or as separate investigations.2

County responses and scrutiny of federal conduct

Orange County Registrar Bob Page said in an email that his office complied with three subpoenas received in September and planned to provide responsive documents for the most recent one. The Chronicle said that subpoena was received Oct. 23 and sought unredacted records for about 60 people. A Santa Clara County spokesperson said the registrar received two federal subpoenas in September.2

In a Tuesday hearing and Wednesday ruling, U.S. District Judge David O. Carter warned First Assistant U.S. Attorney Bill Essayli to stop threatening local election officials. The Chronicle quoted Carter describing the Justice Department's actions as “a broad, ongoing pattern of attempted election interference by federal officials.”2

ABC News reported that multiple unnamed state election officials viewed the warning letters' invocation of criminal liability as a departure from previous administrations' communications. Connecticut Secretary of State Stephanie Thomas said the emphasis on criminal penalties “could have been handled differently.”1

TIMELINE
  1. Orange County Registrar Bob Page said his office complied with three subpoenas received that month; a Santa Clara County spokesperson said the registrar received two federal subpoenas.2

  2. ABC News described Acting Deputy Attorney General Trent McCotter's letter to state election leaders as sent Thursday, reminding them to preserve election materials and warning of penalties for willful noncompliance.1

  3. The Chronicle said Orange County received its most recent subpoena, seeking unredacted records for some 60 individuals; Page said the office planned to provide responsive documents.2

  4. The Chronicle said the subpoena documents set an appearance date in Los Angeles County.2

  5. The Chronicle said the subpoena documents set an appearance date in Orange County.2

WHAT WE STILL DON'T KNOW
  • The precise legal authority (specific U.S. Code sections) cited in the California subpoenas.
  • Whether the DOJ characterizes the California subpoenas as part of a single, coordinated wider inquiry or as separate investigations.
  • The full list of all California counties that have received similar subpoenas.
  • The specific number of individuals whose unredacted records are sought in the recent Orange County subpoena (reported as 'some 60').
  • Whether any recipient has formally challenged a subpoena in court, beyond the judge's comments in an unrelated hearing.
  • The DOJ's official response to Judge Carter's criticism and its characterization of the actions.
SOURCES
  1. 1.
  2. 2.