DOJ seeks to block California mail ballots pending citizenship checks
The department says it gave California a list on October 13 and that the state declined to help verify citizenship; county officials say the information and methodology were insufficient to justify withholding ballots.4,5
The rulings reported so far address emergency efforts to segregate ballots, while the precise statutory or administrative practice challenged in the complaint and the case’s status after the Supreme Court action remain unclear from the available reporting.1,3
- The DOJ’s suit seeks to prevent tabulation of mail ballots tied to more than 20,000 people it calls likely noncitizens, pending citizenship determinations.8
- The DOJ says it provided California a list on October 13 and that state officials declined to assist; Los Angeles County said the department had not provided evidence, sources or methodology establishing that the named people were ineligible.4,5
- Judge David Carter rejected a request to require segregation of roughly 20,000 ballots; Reason reports that his opinion criticized the DHS list for lacking disclosed error rates or validation against a reliable benchmark.3
- The Justice Department says it charged 28 foreign nationals in California with election-related crimes, all of them lawful permanent residents; those charges do not establish convictions.4
- Fox News reports that the Ninth Circuit rejected an emergency request and Justice Elena Kagan later denied the administration’s emergency Supreme Court request; the underlying lawsuit’s status after that action is not specified in the available reporting.1
The Justice Department sued California on October 15, 2026, asking a federal court to stop the state from tabulating mail ballots linked to more than 20,000 people the department describes as likely noncitizens until their citizenship can be determined, CBS News reports.8
The department says California’s refusal to help set ballots aside followed its October 13 delivery of a list for citizenship checks; Los Angeles County said it could not withhold ballots on unverified allegations.4,5
What the Justice Department is asking for
CBS News reports that the DOJ filed suit on October 15, 2026, in the U.S. District Court for the Central District of California. The complaint seeks an order preventing California from tabulating vote-by-mail ballots associated with people the federal government calls “likely noncitizens” until each person’s citizenship status can be determined.8
The DOJ says it gave California a list on October 13 of people whose mail ballots it wanted set aside pending citizenship confirmation, and that California declined to assist. The department says that refusal prompted the lawsuit, which it describes as an effort to prevent unlawful dilution of citizens’ votes.4
Fox News reports that the DOJ’s complaint alleges California is impeding enforcement of federal law barring noncitizens from voting in federal elections and invokes the Constitution’s Supremacy Clause. The report quotes a DOJ filing arguing that counting and commingling unlawful ballots would cause harm that could not be remedied.1
The precise California statute, regulation or administrative practice that the complaint challenges is not specified in the available reporting, nor does it reproduce the complaint’s complete requested relief.1,8
The list and the dispute over its basis
CBS News reports that Acting Deputy Attorney General Trent McCotter sent letters to counties, including Los Angeles, enclosing a password-protected thumb drive that he said contained names compiled by the Department of Homeland Security. The letters gave counties 48 hours to review a list of people suspected of being noncitizens who had allegedly been sent mail ballots.8
Los Angeles County said on October 15 that it could not comply because the DOJ had not supplied evidence, sources or methodology showing that the people identified were ineligible to vote. The county said it could not refuse to count ballots on unverified allegations.5
CBS News reports that Registrar Dean Logan said the county would not review the thumb-drive materials because doing so would conflict with its data privacy and information-security protocols. The same report says Secretary of State Shirley Weber said the DOJ had not provided the list of names and called the administration’s earlier figure of 190,000 noncitizens on the rolls unsubstantiated.8
Reason reports that Judge Carter’s opinion described a DHS process that matched a purchased California voter file through LexisNexis and USCIS records, assigning confidence scores. According to that report, Carter said the government supplied no error rates or validation against a reliable benchmark and did not explain how an initial figure near 200,000 was narrowed to 20,000.3
Fox News reports that Los Angeles County officials’ preliminary review of part of the federal list found apparent discrepancies, including people born in the United States and people who were not registered to vote. The report does not provide the review’s full results or its methodology.6
The Justice Department says the list it provided California contained more than 20,000 people it called likely noncitizen registrants. Acting Deputy Attorney General Trent McCotter said the 28 charged defendants appeared on that list and called for citizenship verification before ballots were counted.4
The cases, charges and figures behind the dispute
The DOJ announced charges against 28 foreign nationals in California, all described by the department as lawful permanent residents, for federal election crimes that include fraudulent voter registration and false statements in naturalization applications. The department said 11 were arrested on October 19, 2026, as part of “Operation Protect the Vote.” These are charges, not reported convictions.4
The Justice Department said that 28 defendants appeared on its list of more than 20,000 likely noncitizen registrants; Yahoo News reports that federal prosecutors charged only 28 California residents with citizen-related voter fraud and that five were not accused of voting.2,4
The reported numbers refer to different stages and categories: Yahoo News says the federal government initially cited more than 190,000 people as potentially registered and later claimed 20,000 were improperly registered, while the DOJ’s list is described elsewhere as containing more than 20,000 people it considers likely noncitizens. Those figures do not, by themselves, establish how many listed people were ineligible or cast ballots.2,4
Yahoo News, republishing reporting by the San Francisco Chronicle’s Sara Libby and Raheem Hosseini, says the DOJ subpoenaed election officials in at least four counties—Los Angeles, Orange, Santa Clara and San Diego—seeking unredacted voter records, including registration, address, voting history and citizenship status. The report also says Los Angeles County Registrar Dean Logan said his office received three federal grand-jury subpoenas.2
The Justice Department’s position is that the list and charges demonstrate a need for the requested ballot restrictions; Acting U.S. Attorney Bill Essayli said California was mailing ballots to noncitizens and refusing to comply with federal law. California officials dispute that characterization and say the federal government has not established that the identified people were ineligible.4,5,7
Emergency requests and rulings
The procedural record described in news reports includes multiple requests to set ballots aside. Reason reports that U.S. District Judge David Carter rejected the DOJ’s request for a temporary restraining order requiring California officials to segregate and stop processing ballots associated with roughly 20,000 voters the government described as likely noncitizens.3
The Epoch Times reports that the DOJ filed a notice of appeal on October 22 after Carter did not rule by the department’s requested noon deadline; the department characterized the lack of a ruling as a “constructive denial” of its emergency application.5
Fox News reports that a three-judge Ninth Circuit panel questioned the administration’s emergency bid during a hearing lasting nearly two hours, including on the government’s legal arguments and the court’s jurisdiction. Fox News also reports that Judge Mark Bennett said the requested injunction appeared inconsistent with California law under the Elections Clause, while Judge Gabriel Sanchez questioned why the circuit should intervene before the district court ruled and Judge Patrick Bumatay focused on the government’s concerns about noncitizen voting.6
Fox News reports that the Ninth Circuit rejected the administration’s request on a Friday, with Bumatay dissenting, and that Justice Elena Kagan, acting alone and without comment, denied the administration’s emergency Supreme Court request on November 2, 2026. The Supreme Court order itself is not included in the available material.1
Fox News reports that on the same evening as the Ninth Circuit action, Chief Judge James Boasberg in Washington issued an injunction blocking the administration from making requests of California concerning its mail ballots. The report says Boasberg found it likely that federal officials had unconstitutionally taken over election responsibilities assigned to states and Congress.1
Fox News reports the appellate and Supreme Court actions but does not specify the subsequent status of the underlying district-court case.1
State authority, election administration and potential effects
Fox News reports that California says it has safeguards against noncitizen voting and argues that the federal list may contain errors capable of disenfranchising eligible voters. The same report says lower courts cited state authority over election procedures and warned that granting the requested segregation could jeopardize the election.1
The DOJ’s stated concern is that ballots cast unlawfully could be counted and commingled with lawful votes, making later relief impossible. California officials’ stated concern is that ballots could not lawfully be withheld on unverified allegations; the dispute therefore concerns both the federal government’s requested check and the risk of acting on an unvalidated list.1,5
Fox News reports that litigation figures showed more than 3 million people had already cast ballots statewide, including more than 500,000 in Los Angeles County. Those figures were reported as part of the dispute over timing; the available claim does not give a date or underlying dataset for the count.6
CBS News reports, as background, that the DOJ’s Civil Rights Division had filed 31 lawsuits seeking unredacted voter rolls, that Harmeet Dhillon sent letters to all 50 states in July warning of possible criminal action over noncitizens on voter rolls, and that the DOJ had lost 26 of those cases with no legal victory to date. The report does not establish the outcome of the California case through that broader litigation history.8
The complaint’s exact requested remedy and the written legal grounds for the Ninth Circuit’s action are not specified in the reporting cited above.6,8
CBS News reports that Civil Rights Division head Harmeet Dhillon sent letters to all 50 states warning of possible criminal action over noncitizens on voter rolls.8
The Justice Department says it provided California a list of people whose mail ballots it wanted set aside pending citizenship confirmation.4
CBS News reports that the DOJ sued California in federal court, seeking to prevent tabulation of ballots linked to people it calls likely noncitizens until their citizenship status can be determined. Los Angeles County said that day it could not comply because the DOJ had not provided evidence, sources or methodology establishing ineligibility.5,8
The Justice Department says 11 of the 28 people it charged in California were arrested as part of “Operation Protect the Vote.”4
The Epoch Times reports that Los Angeles County moved to dismiss the DOJ lawsuit, arguing that the complaint identified no concrete injury traceable to the county’s conduct.5
The Epoch Times reports that the DOJ appealed after Judge Carter did not rule by the department’s requested noon deadline; the DOJ called the absence of a ruling a “constructive denial.”5
Reason reports, citing Judge Carter’s opinion, that the DOJ sent letters to every California county demanding that ballots of alleged noncitizens be set aside and threatening federal charges against officials who did not comply.3
Reason reports that Judge Carter rejected the DOJ’s request for a temporary restraining order requiring California officials to segregate and stop processing roughly 20,000 ballots.3
Fox News reports that Justice Elena Kagan, acting alone and without comment, denied the administration’s emergency Supreme Court request to reverse lower-court rulings blocking segregation of more than 20,000 California mail ballots.1
- What specific California statute, regulation, or administrative practice does the DOJ complaint allege violates federal law? The bundle describes the lawsuit's goal but not the precise legal target.
- What is the exact legal remedy sought in the DOJ's complaint (e.g., a preliminary injunction, a permanent injunction)? Reports say 'segregate ballots' or 'prevent counting,' but the complaint's specific prayer for relief is not provided.
- What methodology did DHS use to generate the list of 'likely noncitizens,' and what is its documented error rate? Judge Carter criticized the lack of this information, but the DOJ's evidence or methodology description is not in the reporting Drasker has located.
- What were the specific legal grounds given by the Ninth Circuit panel for questioning the DOJ's emergency request? The bundle reports judges' questions but not the panel's written order or reasoning.
- What is the current status of the 28 individuals charged? Are they merely charged, or have any been convicted? The bundle only establishes charges have been filed.
- What is the procedural posture of the underlying lawsuit after the Supreme Court denial? Is the district court case ongoing, dismissed, or stayed?
- Which specific California statute, regulation or administrative practice does the DOJ complaint allege violates federal law? The complaint’s precise legal target is not identified in the reporting cited here.
- What exact remedy does the DOJ request in its complaint? Reports describe efforts to segregate ballots or prevent counting, but do not provide the complaint’s specific prayer for relief.
- What methodology did DHS use to generate the list of people labeled “likely noncitizens,” and what is its documented error rate? Reason reports that Judge Carter criticized the absence of error rates and validation information, but the department’s methodology and supporting data are not described in the available reporting.
- What legal grounds did the Ninth Circuit panel give for its action on the emergency request? Fox News reports the judges’ questions but does not provide a written order or the panel’s reasoning.
- What is the current status of the 28 people charged? The Justice Department announced charges, but the available reporting does not establish whether any defendant has been convicted.
- What is the procedural posture of the underlying lawsuit after the Supreme Court action? The available reporting does not say whether the district-court case remains ongoing, was dismissed or is stayed.
- 1.Original reportingFox News — DOJ Appeals Block on 20K California Ballot Segregation
- 2.Original reportingYahoo News — DOJ issues subpoenas for California election officials.
- 3.
- 4.
- 5.
- 6.
- 7.
- 8.
- Revision 2 · November 2, 2026 · material update
- Revision 1 · October 30, 2026