Missouri map dispute reaches Supreme Court again
Missouri’s 2025 map was adopted during a Republican redistricting push; opponents then sought a referendum, and state and federal courts issued conflicting directions about which lines election officials should use.5,7,9
The reported contempt finding concerned Hoskins’ Sept. 8 email directing election officials to use the new map; the email itself and the court’s complete findings are not included in the accounts cited here.7
- Missouri Republicans adopted HB 1 in 2025 during a special session called by Gov. Mike Kehoe; the map was intended to give Republicans seven of the state’s eight U.S. House seats, according to reporting cited by ZeroHedge.9
- The Missouri Supreme Court ruled Sept. 3 that opponents’ referendum petition was valid and that the 2025 map would not take effect unless voters approved it in November, SCOTUSblog reported.5
- A federal judge later ordered use of the 2025 map, the U.S. Supreme Court blocked that order, and the Eighth Circuit subsequently directed Missouri to use the 2025 boundaries, according to SCOTUSblog and Fox News.3,5,7
- The Missouri Supreme Court found Hoskins in contempt over his Sept. 8 email but indicated he had corrected course by directing officials to use the 2022 map, SCOTUSblog reported.7
- The precise text of the email, the full reasoning behind the court orders, and any future contempt-hearing date are not established in the available reporting.5,9
On Sept. 23, Justice Brett Kavanaugh accepted People Not Politicians’ emergency request and directed supporters of the 2025 map to respond by the following afternoon, Fox News reported. The move came after an Eighth Circuit order called for Missouri to use that map in November, setting up another dispute over which boundaries will govern the election.1,3
The Supreme Court had twice previously intervened to keep the older map in use, according to the New York Times; the appeals court’s later ruling reopened the question.2
A new map, then a referendum campaign
Missouri Republicans drew HB 1 during a 2025 special session called by Gov. Mike Kehoe, as part of a wider redistricting effort encouraged by President Donald Trump. The plan was intended to give Republicans seven of Missouri’s eight House seats, including by reshaping the Kansas City-based 5th District held by Democratic Rep. Emanuel Cleaver, according to reporting cited by ZeroHedge.9
Opponents submitted more than 300,000 signatures seeking a statewide vote on the map. SCOTUSblog’s chronology says Hoskins rejected the petition on Aug. 4, 2026, and that von Glahn sued that day.7,9
On Sept. 3, the Missouri Supreme Court unanimously ruled that the petition was “legal, sufficient, and timely,” and that the state constitution allowed a referendum on an act of the legislature. SCOTUSblog reported that the court said the new map could not take effect unless voters approved it in November 2026.5
Conflicting directions from state and federal courts
After the state ruling, Hoskins sought emergency relief. SCOTUSblog reported that Justice Brett Kavanaugh declined his request on Sept. 8 without referring it to the full court; less than an hour later, Chief U.S. District Judge Stephen Clark issued a temporary restraining order directing the state to use the 2025 map.5
The Federalist reported that Clark’s order held that use of a map other than the 2025 map would violate federal law. The Missouri Supreme Court’s referendum ruling pointed the other way, requiring use of the older map unless voters approved the new one, according to SCOTUSblog.4,5
The Eighth Circuit declined to stay Clark’s order, according to SCOTUSblog’s chronology. SCOTUSblog commentary also reported that an appellate panel left the district court’s ruling in place while expressing doubt about its jurisdiction because temporary restraining orders are not ordinarily appealable.6,7
On Sept. 10, the U.S. Supreme Court granted People Not Politicians’ request to block Clark’s temporary restraining order. SCOTUSblog described the order as brief and unsigned, without public dissents; Fox News likewise reported that the court gave no explanation.7,8
The contempt proceeding over Hoskins’ email
SCOTUSblog reported that the Missouri Supreme Court ordered Hoskins to show cause why he should not be held in contempt over a Sept. 8 email instructing election officials to use the 2025 map, and scheduled arguments for 10 a.m. Thursday.5
At a Sept. 10 hearing, the state court found Hoskins in contempt of its Sept. 3 order, SCOTUSblog reported. Chief Justice W. Brent Powell indicated that Hoskins had since corrected the problem by directing officials to use the 2022 map.7
The Federalist separately reported that the state court later treated the contempt as purged after Hoskins complied. The complete email and the court’s order or transcript are not provided in the accounts cited here, so the exact conduct and any penalty cannot be described from those accounts.4,7
The map dispute reopens
On Sept. 22, the Eighth Circuit ordered Missouri to use the 2025 map for the November election, according to Fox News. The New York Times reported that the appeals court’s decision sided with Republicans seeking to use the redrawn boundaries and returned the dispute to the Supreme Court.2,3
The New York Times reported that opponents of the 2025 map filed with the Supreme Court just before midnight Tuesday, asking it to block the appellate order. The appeals court had given the justices until the following Monday evening to decide which map would govern, the Times reported.2
Fox News reported that Kavanaugh accepted People Not Politicians’ emergency request on Tuesday night, Sept. 23, and directed supporters of the 2025 map to respond by Wednesday at 2 p.m. Eastern. Fox described this as the third time the Supreme Court had taken up the case.1
Election preparations and the practical stakes
The New York Times reported that ballots using the older map had been printed and mailed to overseas and military voters the prior week, and that absentee voting by mail and in person began Tuesday. The Times also reported that Missouri’s August primary had been held under the redrawn map.2
The Missouri Association of County Clerks and Election Authorities said it would not use the 2025 map for November, arguing in an appeal filing that there was not enough time to provide new ballots, Fox News reported. People Not Politicians director Richard von Glahn said, “Ballots have been printed, and Missourians have already voted.”1
The New York Times reported that using the older map would likely help Democrats retain both of the state’s congressional seats. Fox News, citing the Associated Press, reported that the change in boundaries could affect more than one million voters.2,8
What the next court action could—and may not—resolve
Kavanaugh’s Sept. 23 action set a response deadline, Fox News reported. SCOTUSblog’s account of the state contempt proceeding described a show-cause hearing and a contempt finding tied to Hoskins’ email, but did not reproduce the email or the full state-court record.1,5,7
ZeroHedge characterized the Supreme Court’s stay as leaving other questions—including standing, the three-judge-court issue and the merits—undecided while the appeal proceeds in the Eighth Circuit. That account interprets the stay’s scope; the order text is not included here.9
The available reporting does not establish the precise legal basis or vote for the Eighth Circuit’s Sept. 22 order, or the full reasoning behind the Supreme Court’s earlier orders.9
Missouri Republicans adopted HB 1 during a special session called by Gov. Mike Kehoe; the map was intended to give Republicans seven of Missouri’s eight House seats, according to reporting cited by ZeroHedge.9
SCOTUSblog’s chronology says opponents submitted more than 300,000 referendum signatures in December.7
Hoskins rejected the referendum petition, and von Glahn sued the same day, according to SCOTUSblog.7
The Missouri Supreme Court unanimously ruled that the referendum petition was valid and that the 2025 map could not take effect unless voters approved it in November, SCOTUSblog reported.5
Kavanaugh declined Hoskins’ emergency request; less than an hour later, Judge Stephen Clark issued a temporary restraining order directing the state to use the 2025 map, according to SCOTUSblog.5
The U.S. Supreme Court blocked Clark’s temporary restraining order, SCOTUSblog reported. The Missouri Supreme Court also held a contempt hearing that day and found Hoskins in contempt over his Sept. 8 email, while indicating he had corrected course.7
The Eighth Circuit ordered Missouri to use the 2025 congressional map for the November election, according to Fox News.3
Kavanaugh accepted People Not Politicians’ emergency request and directed supporters of the 2025 map to respond by Wednesday at 2 p.m. Eastern, Fox News reported.1
- The exact text, vote count, reasoning, and any dissents in the U.S. Supreme Court's Sept. 10 order blocking the 2025 map.
- The full text of the Missouri Supreme Court's Sept. 3 ruling, particularly its legal reasoning authorizing a referendum on the congressional map.
- The complete text of Secretary Hoskins' Sept. 8 email that allegedly triggered the state contempt proceedings.
- The specific findings and any penalty from the Missouri Supreme Court's Sept. 10 contempt hearing regarding Hoskins.
- The precise legal basis and vote (if any) for the Eighth Circuit's Sept. 22 order reinstating the 2025 map.
- The content of the 'unsigned order' from the U.S. Supreme Court referenced in earlier September proceedings, including its page length and any noted dissents.
- Whether a further contempt hearing is scheduled after the Sept. 10 hearing, and what action such a hearing could compel, is not established by the cited court coverage.
- 1.Original reportingFox News — Supreme Court to hear Missouri redistricting case again
- 2.Original reportingNew York Times — Missouri Congressional Map Dispute Heads Back to Court
- 3.Original reportingFox News — Court orders Missouri to use rejected congressional map
- 4.
- 5.
- 6.
- 7.
- 8.
- 9.
- Revision 3 · October 23, 2026 · material update
- Revision 2 · October 4, 2026 · material update
- Revision 1 · October 3, 2026