← Front pageReports · Watch · Archive
DRASKER

DRASKER REPORT

published · Updated October 23, 2026

Supreme Court blocks Missouri’s new map for November

The New York Times said the unsigned five-page order cited the risk of “electoral chaos,” noting that ballots using the 2022 boundaries had already been printed and mailed and that absentee and military and overseas voting had begun.1

The ruling capped a month of litigation in which the Eighth Circuit, state courts and the Supreme Court took actions affecting which map Missouri could use.2,3,4

KEY POINTS
  • The New York Times reported that the Supreme Court’s Sept. 25 action barred use of Missouri’s 2025 map for the November election; the paper said the order pointed to ballots already mailed and absentee voting underway.1
  • Missouri had conducted its August primary using the redrawn map, while the November election was set to use the 2022 boundaries, Fox News reported.4
  • Reason reported that People Not Politicians gathered more than 300,000 referendum signatures and that Secretary of State Denny Hoskins delayed certification; the signature count and timeline remain unverified in the available record.5
  • The Supreme Court’s Sept. 25 order’s vote split and full reasoning are not available in the reporting summarized here; SCOTUSblog and Fox News both described the relevant brief order as lacking detailed reasoning.3,4
WHAT WE KNOW

The U.S. Supreme Court again blocked Missouri from using its redrawn 2025 congressional map in the November election, the New York Times reported on Sept. 25, leaving the 2022 map in place for the general election.1

The Times described it as the court’s third intervention in the dispute that month; its earlier account said two previous interventions had also cleared the way for the older map.1,2

A shifting path through the courts

The Supreme Court’s Sept. 25 action followed a succession of orders over which map Missouri could use. The New York Times reported that the court had intervened twice earlier in September to keep the 2022 map available, and characterized the Sept. 25 action as its third intervention that month.1,2

On Sept. 10, SCOTUSblog columnists Akhil Amar and Vikram Amar described a Supreme Court order reversing or blocking a district court ruling joined by three Eighth Circuit judges. They said the Eighth Circuit had left a temporary restraining order in place while expressing jurisdictional doubt, and that Justice Brett Kavanaugh had earlier denied Missouri’s request for a stay.3

Reason reported that Attorney General Catherine Hanaway, acting for Secretary of State Denny Hoskins, sought a Supreme Court stay that was denied on a Tuesday; it said that minutes later, federal judge Stephen Clark issued a restraining order favoring the new map, which the Supreme Court then paused.5

The New York Times reported that the Eighth Circuit issued a decision Monday night siding with Republicans seeking to use the new map. It also reported that proponents of the older map asked the Supreme Court on Tuesday night to block that decision, and that the appeals court gave the justices until the following Monday evening to decide which map would apply.2

The election calendar and the competing boundaries

The immediate practical issue was which boundaries would govern the November election after Missouri had already held its August primary under the new map. Fox News reported that the November election would use the 2022 boundaries and that the change could affect more than 1 million voters.4

The New York Times reported that ballots using the 2022 map had been printed and mailed to overseas and military voters, and that absentee voting began Tuesday. Its Sept. 25 account said the unsigned Supreme Court decision cited “electoral chaos,” pointing to ballots already mailed and absentee, military and overseas voting already underway.1,2

The New York Times said the older map would position Democrats to retain a Kansas City-area seat; its earlier account said the older boundaries would likely help Democrats retain both of the state’s congressional seats. These are the paper’s descriptions of the maps’ potential political effects, not election results.1,2

The referendum and state-court dispute

Reason reported that People Not Politicians collected more than 300,000 signatures seeking a referendum on the map. Reason said Hoskins delayed certification until just before the primary and then declared the referendum null and void; election-authority records or court filings confirming the signature count and certification timeline are not provided in the available reporting.5

Reason said the Missouri Supreme Court ruled on Sept. 3 that the referendum was legal and the old map should remain in effect for the November 2026 general election. Fox News separately reported that the Missouri Supreme Court blocked the new map and that Missouri would use the 2022 map in November.4,5

The New York Times article does not address the Missouri Supreme Court’s Sept. 3 ruling or the federal district court order’s specific directives, leaving their relationship unclear in that account.1

What the latest order does—and does not explain

The New York Times described the Sept. 25 decision as an unsigned five-page order and quoted its reference to “electoral chaos.” The paper said the order noted that ballots using the 2022 map had been printed and mailed and that absentee and military and overseas voting had begun.1

SCOTUSblog said the Supreme Court’s order did not include detailed reasoning or a documented vote split, and Fox News likewise reported that the brief order did not explain the court’s reasoning. The order itself and its full text are not included in the accounts summarized here.3,4

SCOTUSblog identified the case as People Not Politicians v. Onder, docket number 26A326.3

Reason placed Missouri’s dispute within a broader period in which it said nine states had drafted gerrymandered congressional maps over two years: eight with Republican-controlled legislatures and California, where Democratic Gov. Gavin Newsom approved a statewide gerrymander by referendum.5

TIMELINE
  1. Reason reported that the Missouri Supreme Court ruled the referendum was legal and that the 2022 map should remain in effect for the November general election.5

  2. SCOTUSblog columnists Akhil Amar and Vikram Amar reported a Supreme Court order reversing or blocking a district court ruling in the congressional-districting case.3

  3. Reason reported that the Supreme Court backed the Missouri Supreme Court’s decision barring use of the map drafted by Gov. Mike Kehoe and blocked a federal court order.5

  4. The New York Times reported that the Eighth Circuit had issued a Monday-night decision siding with Republicans seeking to use the redrawn map, and that proponents of the older map had asked the Supreme Court to block it.2

  5. The New York Times reported that the Supreme Court again blocked Missouri from using its redrawn 2025 map in the November election.1

WHAT WE STILL DON'T KNOW
  • The specific, contradictory directives in the Missouri Supreme Court's September 3 ruling versus the federal district court's order.
  • Official election authority verification of the 300,000+ referendum signatures and Secretary of State Hoskins's certification timeline.
  • The U.S. Supreme Court's slip opinion for the September 25 order, including its vote split and full reasoning.
  • The exact docket number and text of the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Eighth Circuit's 'Monday night' decision siding with Republicans.
  • The specific basis cited by Justice Kavanaugh for denying Missouri's earlier stay application.
  • The precise number of voters affected by the map change (Fox cites an AP estimate; official data is absent).
SOURCES
  1. 1.
  2. 2.
  3. 3.
  4. 4.
  5. 5.